Putting an end to one of the most intense high tech legal battles in recent memory, this afternoon Apple and Qualcomm announced that the two firms were burying the hatchet. Effective immediately, all litigation between the two companies has been dropped, and the two have signed new patent license and chip supply agreements. As a result, the face of the cellular modem market is changing in an instant, as Apple’s shift in allegiances will have repercussions throughout the industry.

Overall, the joint press release put out by the two companies is very short on details, as the agreement is largely a private matter. To settle their legal affairs, Apple will be making a one-time payment to Qualcomm, presumably to cover any IP use since Apple cut off payments to Qualcomm in 2017. Replacing those lawsuits, Apple has signed a 6-year patent license agreement with Qualcomm, which is being backdated to April 1st. The agreement includes a further 2-year extension option, which if Apple eventually chooses to exercise it, would take the agreement through April of 2027.

Along with licensing Qualcomm’s patents, Apple is also going to resume buying chips from Qualcomm. A separate chipset supply agreement has been inked; though the official announcement doesn’t say for how long beyond the fact that it’s a “multiyear” agreement. Interestingly the word “modem” does not appear once in the press release itself, but from the nature of the two companies’ conflict and Apple’s own needs, clearly Qualcomm is once again going to be supplying modems for Apple’s iPhones and iPads.

As noted by Reuters, the sudden nature of the deal took many people by surprise. Apple and Qualcomm announced the deal as the two companies were simultaneously in federal court in San Diego, arguing their cases on day 2 of what was their ongoing trial. That trial is now over, as are all of Qualcomm and Apple’s other legal tussles across the world.

Apple and Qualcomm are not announcing the overall financial details of the deal – how much Apple is paying in royalties, nor how much the one-time payment is. However Qualcomm has put out a summary slide disclosing that as product shipments ramp, the company is expecting the deal to bring the company’s incremental earnings to around two dollars per share. Which goes to show just how big of a deal this is in terms of sales and volume, and how important it was for Qualcomm to bring Apple back on board. Accordingly, as noted by CNBC, Qualcomm’s stock had its best day since 1999, with the stock jumping up 23% during market hours, and a further 7% after-hours.

Overall, the consequences of the deal are significant. Qualcomm has been accused across the globe of FRAND violations and other anti-competitive behavior, with Apple serving as Qualcomm’s fiercest critic in this area. While various regulatory cases are still going on – particularly in the US – settling with Apple means that the company will no longer be petitioning regulators and government officials to rule against Qualcomm. So while indirect, this could remove a lot of pressure against Qualcomm in their ongoing regulatory cases.

Meanwhile, Apple’s shift in allegiances has led to their alternative modem supplier, Intel, to drop out of the 5G smartphone market entirely. A few hours after the Qualcomm settlement was announced, Intel made its own announcement that it was exiting the 5G smartphone modem business, and will be reevaluating the rest of its client modem business. So in the span of a day, the 5G modem market has already lost a competitor.

On that note, however, it’s interesting that the chip supply agreement between Apple and Qualcomm isn’t for the same fixed length as their patent agreement. Apple has developed a well-earned reputation for going their own way in chip development, and this may be a sign that Apple intends to eventually develop their own modem technology. This could prove especially prudent, as it would allow Apple to integrate a modem directly into their A-series SoCs, doing away with the need for an external modem and freeing up some valuable PCB space. Fittingly, this is one of Qualcomm’s greatest strengths in the Android SoC space, as the company routinely offers SoCs with various integrated modems.

Source: Apple

POST A COMMENT

14 Comments

View All Comments

  • Teckk - Tuesday, April 16, 2019 - link

    Both public companies, aren't they supposed to reveal more details of the agreement, especially the one time payment? Reply
  • nicmonson - Tuesday, April 16, 2019 - link

    So did Intel quitting the 5G market put more force on Apple to settle or did Apple settling put the final nail in the Intel 5G coffin? Which lead to the other given both these announcements were likely days in the making. Reply
  • nicmonson - Tuesday, April 16, 2019 - link

    Ah, dang. Did not mean to reply to Techkk. Also "would take the agreement through April of 2017" should be changed to 2027 I assume. Reply
  • Raqia - Wednesday, April 17, 2019 - link

    That's a good question, but I think it's pretty likely that the ouster of Krazanich may have set this into motion. Modems were a money losing operation for Intel supported by contra-revenues which sucked up valuable foundry space that could be used for higher margin CPUs.

    Doing business with Apple as a third party seems to be more and more of a losing proposition of late: Intel both lost money per modem and had huge opportunity cost in the CPUs it didn't make; Qualcomm was suddenly starved of contractually obligated licensing revenue and nearly taken under and carved into pieces in a hostile bid by Broadcom; Apple cancelled its order w/ Dialog w/o having another supplier lined up, watched their stock tank, and bought up valuable IP for pennies on the dollar; they ought-right stole Imagination IP when they switched to an in-house GPU; GTAT was bankrupted by a mismanaged (by Apple) attempt to make sapphire for iPhone 6. It takes a big warchest like Qualcomm's and balls of steel to deal with Apple as a counterparty as it will try its hardest to squash you after a few quarters of business.
    Reply
  • blu42 - Wednesday, April 17, 2019 - link

    > So did Intel quitting the 5G market put more force on Apple to settle or did Apple settling put the final nail in the Intel 5G coffin?

    The latter. The one thing that kept Intel modems afloat was the Apple/QCOM feud.
    Reply
  • drexnx - Wednesday, April 17, 2019 - link

    it's a business that makes sense to be in when you've got very underutilized fabs, but Intel can currently sell every processor chip they fab at good margins - they don't want extremely low margin apple modems eating capacity that could be pumping high margin Xeons or middle margin consumer products. Reply
  • peevee - Friday, April 19, 2019 - link

    The keyword is "currently". Next recession will come, companies will stop their PC/server replacement, just by the time Intel finally figures out 10nm, competitors will be on 7nm (or even TSMC 6nm) by that time, and suddenly Intel will find itself with a lot of spare capacity and without any alternative way to utilize it. And capacity is essentially fixed cost - you pay for the fabs (capital costs and most running costs) whether or not you utilize them.

    And it might happen LITERALLY in the matter of months now.
    Reply
  • GreenReaper - Wednesday, April 17, 2019 - link

    Maybe they will - but in their quarterly filings? Or a conference call for investors. Reply
  • patel21 - Wednesday, April 17, 2019 - link

    Why couldn't intel integrate its modems into its CPU's, just as Qualcomm does.
    They can start by releasing just some CPU's with modems for ultra portables. I think there is a big market for such devices.
    Reply
  • shadowx360 - Wednesday, April 17, 2019 - link

    Because Intel's 5G modem doesn't exist. They have never shown any piece of working silicon, and have been blasted on other sites for photoshopped images of their modems. Plus Qualcomm integrates modems onto SoCs, NOT CPUs. On larger devices the SoC is basically the motherboard and CPU. Reply

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now