At the business end of the review, we have to say that CyberLink has got its strategy right. At present, they seem to be the only vendor in the HTPC Blu-ray / DVD software space with a strategy for the next generation of media playback devices. In fact, CyberLink also showed their softwares in action in the Windows 8 Metro UI during CES. CyberLink deserves a lot of credit for moving ahead quickly in this area. However, all the components have scope for improvement, and we also have some suggestions on possible features to integrate in the future:

PowerDVD:

  1. The software needs an option to turn off Internet access unless explicitly requested by the user (as in the case of BD-Live). Whenever one tries to resume a movie, PowerDVD fetches information about the latest Blu-rays and displays it in a pane on the right side while presenting the Resume / Restart screen. Frankly, I don’t see too many consumers actually being interested in looking at the new offerings when trying to restart their movies.
  2. The software could implement native support for Blu-ray / DVD ISOs, thereby making it unnecessary for users to mount them in a virtual drive. Compatibility with folder rips could be improved.
  3. It would be nice to have the audio playback method (bitstream / decode / downmix) selectable from the context menu during playback. By default, most users with A/V receivers would be setting the audio method to bitstream. When watching PiP video, it is necessary to decode the primary audio and mix it with the decoded secondary audio. Unfortunately, PowerDVD keeps bitstreaming the primary audio and there is no way out other than to go a couple of levels down into Settings and Audio to fix the issue. In my opinion, the drop-down approach from the AV Center used by Total Media Theater is much better.
  4. It would be good to have PowerDVD bypass the sound processing by Windows (particularly when decoding, say, a 5.1 channel FLAC to LPCM, Windows expands the 6 channel LPCM from PowerDVD to a 8 channel LPCM stream to the AV receiver, rendering the AVR incapable of doing its own channel expansion)
  5. Auto change to 3D mode is a bit dicey, particularly for 3D photo files, but one can’t find too much fault with PowerDVD for that.
  6. It is interesting to see premium media outlets like 7Digital adopting PowerDVD as a distribution medium. Having used PCs as their stepping stone, premium OTT services such as Netflix now treat them as poor second cousins. 1080p HD quality and multi-channel DD+ audio are reserved for streaming STBs. Some of the reasons cited for this are lack of playback apps on the PC with the required codec licenses and security of the data stream. Given that PowerDVD is secure enough for Blu-ray and also has the required codec licenses, it would be nice to have the highest quality streams from Netflix, Vudu and other similar services made available to consumers

PowerDVD Mobile:

  1. Despite CyberLink’s claims of real-time transcoding to enable DLNA playback, we could get transcoding to work only when saving the media stream to the mobile device. Also, this transcoding doesn’t seem to be taking advantage of QuickSync.
  2. Multiple player engine support is crucial. Currently, the app relies only on hardware decode (using the default playback settings of the local device as defined in the OS/image of the tablet/smartphone). I found a number of dedicated uPnP playback apps which played more media formats in a reliable manner compared to PowerDVD Mobile.
  3. Media can only be arranged by folders or in an all-inclusive view. Support for arrangement based on other factors (like date, size etc.) would be a nice feature to have.
  4. The app already supports local media. It would be nice to extend this support to media files residing on SMB and NFS network shares also.
  5. The app could be made more responsive. Currently, it feels very beta in nature. Performance was acceptable, but not great. It is not clear whether the issues were with the platforms or the app itself, but I did find other dedicated uPnP playback apps a pleasure to use.

PowerDVD Remote:

  1. The app could have a landscape mode option along with orientation auto-detection.

Wrapping things up, PowerDVD 12 is a laudable attempt by CyberLink to adapt to the evolving lifestyle of the consumers. As the tablet and smartphone platforms become more pervasive, CyberLink seems to be best poised to provide users with compelling offerings. Given that almost all Blu-ray / DVD software players come in at approximately the same price ($100), it looks like a no-brainer to go in with PowerDVD 12 because of the various mobile apps (unless you can purchase the competition's offerings at a much lower price).





 

PowerDVD Mobile v4
Comments Locked

41 Comments

View All Comments

  • Spivonious - Tuesday, January 31, 2012 - link

    I knew there was a reason version 11 was on a fire sale. I had to upgrade from 9 to play those profile 5 discs. Hopefully they continue support for 11 for a while.
  • jwcalla - Tuesday, January 31, 2012 - link

    Maybe I'm just a curmudgeon but the idea of having to pay for software to get the magic keys to play the BluRay discs you paid for is ridiculous. Why are people so eager to grab their ankles?
  • Spivonious - Tuesday, January 31, 2012 - link

    That cost is included with standalone players. That said, I'd love it if Microsoft would sell a blu-ray codec for $10-$15 and let me play them right inside of Media Center. I will never use the mobile features of PowerDVD, nor the image enhancement and fake 3D features.
  • Tetracycloide - Wednesday, February 1, 2012 - link

    I can understand a commercial license being needed to release the codec as part of a retail player but a non-commercial home license should be totally free.
  • Alexstarfire - Friday, February 3, 2012 - link

    Yes, the cost might be included with the stand-alone players but you're also paying for the hardware. When you are playing back Blu-Rays/DVDs on your computer you've already paid for the hardware. I see no reason that the software would be as expensive as a solution that provides hardware and software. I don't believe it should be free, though that'd be very nice, but even $50 is more expensive than I think it should be.
  • Tetracycloide - Wednesday, February 1, 2012 - link

    Wholeheartedly agree. Wasn't there an article here a few days back about adding blu-ray support to VLC by just copying the keys into the right folder? Maybe that was ars. At any rate it's infinitely preferable to paying for the bars and chains that keep you locked up as a consumer.
  • ganeshts - Wednesday, February 1, 2012 - link

    Yes, VLC can handle Blu-rays with encryption now (albeit with some exceptions).

    But, VLC will not be reliable with menus, HD audio decoding etc. (Look up the VLC piece I wrote in the Pipeline section as to why Blu-ray support being added in VLC is just the beginning of a long process)
  • joel4565 - Tuesday, January 31, 2012 - link

    I am sure the latest version of Powerdvd is quite nice and lovely, but honesty how can it ever be justified at $100 for the full version when a quick glance on Newegg shows several standalone blueray players for <$100 and several well rated at just over a hundred dollars.

    And for tablet/mobile For the same ~$100 you could get a two year subscription to AnyDVD HD and Handbrake to transcode the video to x264 for a much better tablet experience. AVplayerHD is a good IOS app that plays 720p x264 mkv videos quite nicely on ipad2 and I am sure there is a similar app for Android.

    The fact that bluray drives require such expensive software to get the full experience shows just how little the movie & tv industry cares about PC users. Even the cheapest bluray drive $57 + the basic version of software $50 is more expensive than several stand alone players that will probably do a better job.
  • daneren2005 - Tuesday, January 31, 2012 - link

    Of course. In fact they HATE PC users. PC users tend to want to do crazy stuff like own content and to be able to use it on multiple devices after paying for it the first time. The media industry on the other hand wants you to pay for the same crap every single time you get a new device, and PCs allow you to get around that.
  • Braumin - Tuesday, January 31, 2012 - link

    I bought version 7 Ultra for HD-DVD and Blu-ray. Verion 9 came out with Media Center integration, so I figured that was worth the upgrade.

    Cyberlink is a horrible company. They never had updates for 9, even when it was the most current offering. Movies would often not play for months before there was updates. Of course, that got worse as 9 moved out of main support.

    $100 is basically a subscription for this software, since they release a new version every year and ditch support of the old version quickly.

    I stopped trying to watch blu-ray on my HTPC. For $90 I got a Samsung wi-fi blu-ray player which has played every disc I have thrown at it.

    Keep your junk Cyberlink.

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now