SilverStone GD04 HTPC Case: Cool, Not Quiet
by Dustin Sklavos on December 25, 2010 12:00 AM EST- Posted in
- Cases/Cooling/PSUs
- HTPC
- SilverStone
- GD04
Conclusion: Good, With Caveats
First, let's be clear, the SilverStone GD04 isn't a poorly designed case; on the contrary, it's actually very well designed. Aesthetically it has a nice minimalist feel to it, and at no point did I ever feel like any of the parts used in its assembly were particularly cheap. It's solid, the feet don't feel like they're going to peel off at the first sign of trouble, and the internal design is fairly smart given the generally small overall character of the case. It's not the smallest case I've built in, but it maximizes both the space it gives you and the cooling power it can have within that space. Which is part of the problem.
Three 120mm fans at high speeds make noise, and that's a real concern when you're dealing with a media center case. For other builds it may not be as big of an issue, but if the GD04 is going to be sitting in your living room it needs to draw as little attention to itself as possible. So while the LED on the front is a low key blue, in a quiet room the case in a typical configuration is going to be very audible. Having to go back and buy a fan controller to keep noise down to a reasonable level wasn't what I had in mind when I bought this case. You could probably get better results by carefully selecting your motherboard, or you might even swap out the default fans for something quieter (or disable one or two fans), but that all adds to the cost as well and may have undesirable results.
Everything else about it is at least understandable: while a more tool-less approach would've been appreciated, it's not absolutely necessary and more of a convenience. I do appreciate how solid the case feels overall, and I can't stress this enough: it feels sturdy and you don't end up feeling ripped off by the $99 price tag it typically commands (shopping around may find you a better deal). That price is actually a good deal lower than what you'll spend for many other HTPC cases, so if you don't need an LCD front panel or anything fancy it's a fine choice. Just know that when you order the GD04 you're going to want to factor in the cost of an additional fan controller, and it's probably going to be the Xigmatek I used since that was the only expansion slot-mounted fan controller I could find on NewEgg. That adds another ten bucks to the price of the case.
At the end of the day I can recommend the GD04 with that caveat: if you think noise in a quiet room will be an issue you're going to want to buy a suitably quiet CPU cooler and a fan controller or a motherboard with enough fan headers and decent fan control. Other than that, the thermals are reasonable, the case looks good, and the price is right. Just keep your screwdriver handy.
Facebook
Twitter
RSS
68 Comments
View All Comments
micksh - Saturday, December 25, 2010 - link
I use Antec P182 case for my desktop. It is a great case for quiet PC, their sound dampering panels do a good job. Something that can't be found in any HTPC case. P150 has similar design, except it doesn't have a front door and it's a bit smaller.But I could not tolerate Antec fans even at minimum settings. P150 has the same Antec 3-speed fans, AFAIK. Just check silentpcreview.com forum, everybody is replacing them.
PC Power & Cooling may make very good PSUs, I don't know. It is just whether PSU makes 12 or 18 dBA of noise it becomes very important for quiet PC. These brands that I listed are known to be very quiet. They would produce less than 15 dBA of noise for that PC. Not ridiculous 36 dBA that was measured in the article.
Nexus Value 430W PSU would be ideal for that kind of PC if CPU was not too power hungry.
I don't think 2.5" HDDs are less reliable. I had one in laptop that was 5 years old and it was still alive when I replaced it.
I use 2.5" HDDs in Scyche enclosures in 2 HTPCs just for silence. Because 3.5" drives can't normally fit in HTPC being put inside silencing enclosure.
SSD is not a necessity if you have 4GB of RAM. 7200 rpm laptop drive is good enough for a system drive. It is just that they are a bit louder than 5400 rpm drives and 5400 rpm drives are a bit slow for a boot drive.
Although, most people would be OK with 7200 rpm laptop HDD noise, I think.
AMD CPU idle power usage can't compete even with Intel Core 2 line. They require more cooling and more speedy fans = more noise. Especially quad core model that article author chose.
MeanBruce - Saturday, December 25, 2010 - link
Micksh, you have some great information and I wish AnandTech would present more articles for us silent enthusiasts. At first I did what you did, I shopped for quiet, quality PSUs Nexus, Zalman, etc. But this last time around I went a step further, I bought the most efficient PSU I could find(at the time) a Corsair HX-850, and I didn't consider any db noise fan specs because I planned on replacing the fan after the first few days of use. It's not the most economical way to put together a silent pc, breaking the amazing 7-year Corsair warranty, by opening the PSU, and another $25 for a Noctua fan, but you end up with an amazingly quiet pc. Not everyone wants to get inside a power supply, but the extra effort pays off!micksh - Saturday, December 25, 2010 - link
Yes, replacing PSU fan is also a way to get quieter PC. If you already have good PSU and are ready to void warranty. Even $10 Scythe Slipstream would probably do the job, maybe with some $3 resistor. $25 Noctua is surely a safer bet.But if new fan is not adequate it may eventually break PSU.
If you want to spend more you can't go wrong with Seasonic X650 Gold PSU. Its fan is not spinning at low loads, it's essentially passive when you watch movies (if your system consumes 150W or less during that, which should be the case).
The fan will start only during gaming when silence is not that important and it still will be quiet.
I think the most difficult part in building quiet PC is silencing hard drive (if you need it).
I have a server in garage that I can stream media from but having some local storage seems comfortable for me.
These days boot SSD are relatively cheap so the need in that is diminished for some.
There are components that generally produce much more noise but you can get very quiet parts for a bit more money.
Power supplies, video cards (up to GTX460 or HD6850 level), CPU coolers, case fans, all can be gotten very quiet if you do some research.
Then at some point HDD becomes the noisiest part. If you reach the stage when soft-mounted 2.5" 5400 rpm HDD is the loudest part of your build and you can silence it (or ditch it) - then you get a quiet computer.
PS. I missed phrase in article that says the distance was 1 foot when measuring noise. I think noise would be 30 dB or more at one meter, still way too loud.
micksh - Saturday, December 25, 2010 - link
Another point of the article - loud blu-ray drive. That will be too difficult to silence even in well shielded case with soft mounts.Try software solutions, something like Nero DriveSpeed. There are others. These would limit disk spinning speed and reduce the noise. They work but the effect may or may not be sufficient depending on you drive and noise requirements.
I play movies from HDD only right now so this is not relevant to me.
Freeco - Saturday, December 25, 2010 - link
I have this case since September and am very happy with it.I did replace the 3 stock fans with 2 Nexus 120mm fans and a Zalman FanMate 2 controller. I didn't even try those stock fans. I replaced them right away because of my good experience with them in my desktop.
Combine that with a Scythe Big Shuriken CPU cooler and a Nexus Value PSU and the result is a dead silent HTPC. I can only hear it if I put my ear right next to it.
Building a silent HTPC is all about choosing the right components...
mingus - Saturday, December 25, 2010 - link
With the Big Shuriken, is there enough room for sound and video cards?I used and Enermax ECO80+ 400w PSU, not sure why, usually use Seasonic. seems quiet, hard to tell.
CPU cooler was some sort of Nexus thing.
Freeco - Sunday, December 26, 2010 - link
off coarse. The Big Shuriken might be big, but not huge ;-)It doesn't overhang the PCIe slots.
See picture on my site (in Dutch, but pics & specs don't have a language ;-)):
http://www.weytens.net/pc_hw_htpc.html
maxfisher05 - Saturday, December 25, 2010 - link
I have a similar build as Freeco. I bought this case in July, paired it with 2 nexus 120mm fans (the 3 stock fans are loud, but 3 fans is overkill anyway). I have a scythe big shuriken cooler on a i-530 and a 5770 video card, both of which are low power and fairly quiet components.Bottom line, I never hear any noise out of this case when doing normal HTPC tasks and I love my build. I'm guessing if I ran prime and maxed out the fans it would make noise...
Oscarcharliezulu - Saturday, December 25, 2010 - link
Thx for the review, but I'd have to agree that the choice of components needed more research if you wanted a quiet PC, and even then some advertised so called quiet components aren't. A htpc can be real trial and error and I think the readers are looking for reviews that provide more than pure observation, or at least I am. Thanks to the posters who write in with what works for them. Personally I have found the low power Athlons and boards with built in gpu's excellent for htpc work. Big fans set to low speed also critical as are green drives. SSD for boot disk will be my next must have upgrade firstly for quicker boots secondly for low noise. I plan to set my recordings or download to a spinning disk then copy once complete to the ssd to run fast and quiet ( I don't have a NAS or server).MeanBruce - Saturday, December 25, 2010 - link
Oscar is right, it really depends on your personal definition of quiet. Most so called silent fans produce around 18 to 20db, which is fine for most people, htpc or if your pc is on the floor. But if like me you prefer your desktop to be on your desktop then the really sweet noise levels are below 10db. The Cooler Master 200mm fans are way too loud out of the box, yet attenuate down to a wonderful 8db with a Noctua blue inline resistor, and still move a great deal of air. Noctua also makes the uln series of fans which are rated at 6db. Also replacing the stock psu fan with a 10db 140mm Noctua and using SSDs for all internal storage and you will be in silent heaven.