Closing Thoughts

The new pattern of a spring and fall (or fall and spring, depending on your location) update for Windows 10 has worked well for 2017. The Creators Update added some new features, and several under the hood changes, but also missed out on a couple of features that were originally promised to hit the early update. Luckily, there’s another update six months later to target, so missed features aren’t missed for too long.

After a relatively tame Creators Update, there’s a lot of great new features in the Fall Creators Update, including the much-missed OneDrive Files On-Demand, which, for me, could have been the entire update. It’s great to finally have access to all of OneDrive, even if you don’t have enough disk space to store everything, which is often the case when SSDs are generally too small for bulk file storage. After a couple of weeks, the new Files On-Demand feature has been flawless, without apps randomly crashing as they wait for files to be downloaded, which wasn’t the case back in Windows 8.1.

Mixed Reality was a major selling point from Microsoft, but it’s still too early to know if this is going to take off in any meaningful way. The hardware is still expensive, although there’s a lot more options now with Mixed Reality, and the benefits are difficult to justify outside of a few select use cases. The AR portion of Mixed Reality might have more of an impact, with the Mixed Reality Viewer where you can project 3D objects into live space. Microsoft has gone pretty heavily into 3D animation, and VR/AR, but the jury is still out on it.

The people-first experiences are where Microsoft can really shine, and the My People has the potential to be a very nice tool. It needs more app integrations to really take off, but early use has been promising.

Photos has also suddenly become very powerful, with the ability to create and edit videos right in Photos itself. Originally this was announced as a separate app, but rolling it into Photos seems like a smart way to get it noticed, and hopefully used, since it does some cool effects without a lot of work.

The new security features are very strong, and should help drive adoption of Windows 10 in the enterprise. But even for the home user, or small business, controlled folder access is a great feature to protect your most important data.

Windows itself looks better than ever, and Fluent Design has been a nice refresh of the look of Windows 10. The lighting effects and acrylic give a nice touch to apps that leverage it. We’re still not at the point where all of Windows, or its apps, have fully embraced Fluent Design, but the initial apps and settings that support it really do look great.

Edge has continued to improve, and this update’s addition of PDF annotation is a very welcome change. Edge was difficult to recommend as a daily browser for a long time, but feature improvements have helped a lot, and it’s now generally good enough for most tasks. There’s still some features not available in Edge that were in IE, or Chrome, but the list gets shorter with every update.

Overall, the Fall Creators Update has been a very nice feature update, building off the Creators Update earlier in the year. The naming convention still needs a lot of work, but that’s not a huge concern. The rollout for the Fall Creators Update has been quicker as well, so Microsoft must be getting more confident in their update process. If your machine hasn’t gotten the update yet, head on over to Microsoft.com to download it and check it out.

Security Updates
Comments Locked

95 Comments

View All Comments

  • Cryio - Friday, November 10, 2017 - link

    I like the few fluent design elements in Start and Action Center. But why doesn't the Taskbar has it?
    Why are most Win32 application chrome window full solid color, a la W8?
    Why does Edge get so few features when releases are either 6 to 9 months apart? Most other browsers seem to add a lot of features every 4/5 weeks. But not Microsoft.

    Anyway, Edge being faster/efficient/more reliable is a welcome improvement.
    Acrylic is nice.
    People is nice, if useless at the moment.
    Polishing Action Center is nice.
    Mixer improvements are nice.

    Aaaaand I still hate that Skylake on Surface Pro 4 at least limits CPU speed to 800 MHz when watching Youtube videos using Edge.
  • StormyParis - Friday, November 10, 2017 - link

    "The new pattern of a spring and fall (or fall and spring, depending on your location)"

    or Autumn ?
  • Zak - Friday, November 10, 2017 - link

    "anit-cheating" typo? On the "Gaming Updates" page.

    Also, besides bringing back some depth and transparencies there is zero in this update for me. Gaming Mode is something disable first. Leave my games alone Microsoft. Microsoft *does not* get PC gaming.
  • Bixx - Friday, November 10, 2017 - link

    You forgot the "feature" where many people's start menu won't work anymore or is missing most items. Over 400 people on the MS forum have this problem (which mean many more "out there" surely do too), yet MS hasn't even acknowledged the problem).
  • Gunbuster - Friday, November 10, 2017 - link

    Or as I like to call it the creators update update.

    Someone at Microsoft now runs a team devoted to creating updates for creators update update.
  • jgeis - Friday, November 10, 2017 - link

    It's probably worth mentioning that there's a problem with clean installs of Windows 10 Fall Creator's Update (1709) where opening Edge browser causes the State Repository Service process to spike your CPU to 100% and essentially locks up the PC. You can get around this by installing another browser off a USB stick, but it's really annoying on a fresh build. Some other actions also seem to trigger it, as well.
  • B3an - Friday, November 10, 2017 - link

    You never go in to enough detail for these updates. Your articles always miss out loads of new stuff and changes. The only reason i visit this site is for in-depth articles, not "The Verge" level crap, minus the SJW shit.
  • Ryan Smith - Friday, November 10, 2017 - link

    B3an, was there something in particular you were looking for that you didn't see? We're still trying to figure out the right level of depth for these Windows updates, especially since they're not wholly new OSes, and a lot of feature information is published ahead of time.

    (None the less, this was still 6K word, 10 page article)
  • SkyDiver - Friday, November 10, 2017 - link

    How sad all of this is. The horror story continues ever since Win8. It still looks flat and dead. So many things wrong with this "operating system."
  • Lolimaster - Friday, November 10, 2017 - link

    Isn't it funny all this "for the user" naming MSFT uses for Windows Spyware 10, each "fancy name" iteration breaks 5 more thing than the one it fixes.

    Windows 10 Fallen to the crapper edition.

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now