The IBM POWER8 Review: Challenging the Intel Xeon

Software Issues

So although the S824 is IBM's benchmark flagship for the scale-out range, the S812L and S822L are the servers that have the best chance at converting the kinds of users currently opt for x86 Xeons:

• Support for Little Endian data
• Best Linux support (Suse, Redhat & Ubuntu)
• (Somewhat) lower power
• 2U form factor which offers decent performance per U
• and probably the most important reason of all: Affordable! ($10k-25k instead of $30-60k)

So yes, the S822L looks like the first worthy alternative since 2010 for the dual Xeon servers. But the S822L did not inherit all the strong points of the typical "Big Blue" servers. The clockspeeds are a bit lower to keep the power consumption in check, and more importantly the LE Linux support is still very young. Sure, POWERLinux has been around for ages, but the software ecosystem was mostly supporting a few Big Endian applications like heavy duty Java servers and SAP.

Let's make the issue at hand a bit more tangible. IBM offers a migration advisor that helps developers to port their applications. That is definitely a good thing, but it also clearly illustrates that building a software ecosystem is a lot more cumbersome than the POWERPoint slides let you believe. In case of IBM's LE Linux, porting the rich x86 Linux software ecosystem to OpenPOWER is not that straightforward:

• Some code has inline x86 assembly such as thread resource locking code.
• Some code has x86 specific APIs
• No support for POWER in the make files which makes recompiling not straight forward
• POWER is 64 bit only.

We have experienced ourselves that this was more than just theory.

Case in point: for X86-64 we simply installed well tuned, ready to run, pre compiled binaries. Benchmarking is pretty easy here with a minor scripting effort.

The story was very different on the IBM S822L. We installed Ubuntu 15.04 (3.19.0-15 - ppc64le). To satisfy our curiosity we did a quick benchmark run with Linux-Bench, an automated benchmarking tool that Ian also likes to use. The benchmark did almost nothing on our POWER system despite the fact that most of the software had some form of support for POWER based systems.

The same was true for most software out there: We had to port most of the software by delving deep in all kinds of config, Readme, and make files. In many cases, we had to search around for alternative libraries that did support OpenPOWER.

Although a lot of software had an entry for "IBM POWER" in the make files, we encountered a lot of trouble. The server nor IBM is to blame: it is simply a fact that most developers - especially those with HPC software - have put a lot more effort in optimizing and validating their Intel x86 version of their software than the more "exotic" platforms.

Linux Ecosystem Not at Full Throttle.. Yet

It is clear to us that the OpenPOWER Linux ecosytem is still young and as a result does not offer the same performance as the older PowerVM and AIX platforms. There is still quite a bit of performance headroom.

A good example is the crypto acceleration. The IBM POWER8 has a dedicated cryptographic unit supporting new POWER ISA instructions to accelerate AES (Encryption), SHA (Hashing), and CRC (Cyclic Redundancy Check) codes. A similar encryption unit was already available in the POWER7+ . We found out that an nx-crypto driver was available and part of the Linux 3.5 kernel. However, even though Ubuntu 15.04 LE for OpenPOWER is based upon the Linux kernel 3.19, the nx-crypto driver was nowhere to be found. You could argue that the same is true for Intel as they introduce new instructions, but as far as we could see, there was no encryption acceleration whatsoever possible, not even based upon the older POWER7+.

A few days after we have finished testing, we found out the vmx-crypto driver will be available in distributions using the Kernel 4.1 and later and will be enabled in OpenSSL 1.0.2 (currently 1.0.1f in the standard repositories). The slide below - found in a presentation given this month - show how fast the ecosystem is expanding but also that it is still in flux.

OpenPOWER gained traction in 2014, the POWER8 is the first POWER chip with LE support and the number of Linux servers on top of OpenPOWER systems is still very small compared to x86. It is pretty simple: it is a much smaller community than the x86 linux server community. According to "the platform", IBM claims that "scale-out POWER8 machines have seen double digit revenue growth in the first half of 2015" but those growth numbers are "against a very small base". That tells us a lot: it is indeed a very small community, but a quickly growing one.