Antec P280 Review: When Enthusiasts Are Engineers
by Dustin Sklavos on November 15, 2011 10:20 AM EST- Posted in
- Cases/Cooling/PSUs
- Antec
- P280
Noise and Thermal Testing, Stock
Despite being very enthusiastic about the design of the Antec P280, I had real concerns about performance in practice. I'm just not a fan of negative pressure designs; historically I've seen positive pressure cases produce better thermal results. Antec's reps even asked me about my experiences there, but thankfully the P280 can be configured that way and then some. I also don't like the two exhaust fans in the top; I've never liked top exhaust fans in cases, as it's always seemed like a great way for noise to leak out. So suffice to say, I entered the actual testing of the P280 with some trepidation.
Performance for the P280 is for the most part middle-of-the-road. I think its biggest competitor is probably the up and coming Fractal Design Define R3. What's worth noting is the very minimal impact running the fans at low speeds seems to have had on the enclosure's performance.
Turning down those fans results in one of the quietest cases we've tested under load, though the results are within the margin of error compared to Fractal Design's Define R3. When we let them ramp up, though, no amount of sound dampening can really save the P280. Thankfully running them at low barely affects thermals, and as a result we get decent performance from a quiet case. So far Antec is on the right track.
Facebook
Twitter
RSS
164 Comments
View All Comments
Skydmark - Wednesday, November 16, 2011 - link
Dustin your reviews are spot on and very detailed. Keep up the good work.Where's the P280 Mini? This would be money in the bank.
I have an Antec Sonata II and Sonata III and love them both, because they are so quiet and elegant looking.
But there are a few things wrong with these cases. The cable routing is non-existent. The motherboard tray doesn't have a CPU cut out for mounting after market coolers. The back panel isn't removable. And changing out hardware is a royal pain in the behind.
Fractal Design turned my head today, because I discovered they make cases that incorporate all this functionality and look elegant at the same time. The ARC Define MID Tower, Define R3 and Define Mini are everything I’m looking for. The drive sleds look like they were taken right out of my Sonatas and painted white. I can’t believe it! This is where Antec should have taken their Sonata line up in the last few years. What happened Antec?
The P280 is a step in the right direction for Antec and the design incorporates changes that people want to see nowadays, but the case is way too big for my taste. Shrink it into a P280 Mini and it might just win me over.
War - Wednesday, November 16, 2011 - link
My first build was with an Antec case. After that I tried a couple other brands but my favorite by far was Antec. This new case looks like it holds to excellent engineering that they started with and does it one better.StepanPepan - Wednesday, November 16, 2011 - link
I have no idea, why did they put only two in the top? Why not three? There is enough place for them and having ability to place 360 rad there would be very nice!I have a question for reviewer: what is the gap between side of the HDD cage and left door? I placed pump there in R3 and the gap is large enough to conveniently pass the tubes there. I am wondering if this could be done in this case too?
lithium451 - Wednesday, November 16, 2011 - link
Considering the two year wait since P183 I'd say somewhere between a single or double.- I'd love to see 140mm capabilities for the fans
- Can't see from the pictures, but I'm guessing the power and reset button on the top may be too easy to get pressed by accident.
- Where their main competitor provides covering for unused fan openings, it seems like a pretty big oversight for Antec not too.
- Not exactly sold on the pointy corners at the top of the front door. Would at least like to see darker color door option to de-accentuate.
The big selling point for me is the 170mm cooler clearance (I think Define R3 is published as 165mm).
The pricing I've seen online ($120-125) does seem a medium premium for a medium increase in quality over the R3. Not sure which way I'll go, but the good news is the R3 price online does seem to have just dropped back to $99 (from $109).
Gabby-Dave - Wednesday, November 16, 2011 - link
I have owned a couple of P180's, which I liked. Except for the dual chamber - a real pain.Although it's a bit heavy, if it helps keep it quiet then that's OK. I especially like the connectors placed at the top front of the case for convienience. And the interior is a rock-solid layout too.
DrForBin - Wednesday, November 16, 2011 - link
Antec installed a vent for the PSU. With a filtre no less! Good on them.infoilrator - Wednesday, November 16, 2011 - link
Changes (updates) were needed and it looks like all "issues" have been more than addressed. I like it.Design and Egineering were looking ahead, and succeeded.
Workable, buildable, quality, longevity.
ouch8s - Wednesday, November 16, 2011 - link
now that I've moved all my HDs out of my main workstation and put in an SSD, i'm ready for a new case that will help reduce the noise even more. looking forward to playing with this one.tmheroes - Wednesday, November 16, 2011 - link
22.3 lbs. seems rather light.hawktrio - Wednesday, November 16, 2011 - link
Back in the late 90's I owned a computer shop and the best decision we ever made was to use Antec cases and power supplies in all of our system builds for customers. After mucking about with cheap PSUs in enclosures (very common in those days) that used to tear your hands apart worse than your neighbours cat, I hardly remember an Antec PSU coming back for warranty! Years later my shop is long gone but I am forever keeping tabs on Antec and still own a number of their fine cases... something like the P180 series and now this new P280 will only continue to pique my interest... thanks Anandtech and Antec... I love you both!