The ASUS ROG Phone II Review: Mobile Gaming First, Phone Second
by Dr. Ian Cutress on September 30, 2019 11:00 AM EST- Posted in
- Mobile
- Asus
- Qualcomm
- Smartphones
- ROG
- RGB
- Snapdragon 855 Plus
- ROG Phone II
Daylight Photography Hands-On
One of the benefits of being a photography luddite is that the quality of smartphone cameras, both the hardware and the software, has come on leaps and bounds over the last decade. Smartphone photography is something that new entrants to the smartphone scene have difficulty on, because the main players are on their ninth or tenth generation of AI-accelerated photography features. If you are new with your first/second generation device, it is hard to play catch-up. But for today, Huawei is one of the companies leading the scene in computational photography.
For my short photography test, I have the ROG Phone II as well as two other flagships on hand: the Mate 30 Pro and the P30 Pro. I took seven day-time scenes from a trip to compare and contrast. All three phones are running in Auto mode, taking 10/12MP shots with pixel binning, with AI enabled.
Position 1: A Church
Mate 30 Pro | P30 Pro | ROG Phone II
Here we can see that the Mate 30 Pro is a little hazier around the words on the right, but the bricks on the wall of the Mate 30 Pro have a lot less noise on them. The ROG Phone II darkens the shadows quite a bit, whereas the two Huawei phones blend the scene a lot better.
Position 2: Clock Tower
Mate 30 Pro | P30 Pro | ROG Phone II
In this instance the P30 Pro is darker on the brickwork than the Mate 30 Pro, however the Mate 30 Pro is a bit more hazier with less detail. Both phones used ISO 50 for this one, with the Mate 30 being at 1/4219s shutter speed compared to 1/3425s. The ROG Phone looks less detailed.
Position 3: Ealing Studios
This photo had a slight angle towards an incoming sun, to give a more difficult scene.
Mate 30 Pro | P30 Pro | ROG Phone II
Again we see that on the P30 Pro, compared to the Mate 30 Pro it is a little darker and in this case the building looks a lot bluer as a result. The sidewalk on the P30 Pro also looks blue, but on the Mate 30 Pro is truer to the real color. Again, the ROG Phone II comes out with less detail.
Position 4: Macaroons
The artificial light here gives an interesting perspective – all three phones typically refresh at 60 Hz, but with the UK on its 50 Hz lighting system combined with a rolling shutter means that we get those wavy lines across the screen. Most modern smartphones now have a way of dealing with this, by detecting the light differential and synchronizing up. It still takes a good 5 seconds or so for the detection to work and kick in, however.
Mate 30 Pro | P30 Pro | ROG Phone II
The Mate 30 Pro makes the colors pop a bit more than the other two, but again we are getting some haziness in the camera and a lack of edge clarity in the distance or even on the yellow macaroons near the front.
Position 5: Ice Cream
Mate 30 Pro | P30 Pro | ROG Phone II
This is more of a close up shot, and again we see the Mate 30 Pro make the colors seem more vibrant, but still a haziness in the image. I wonder if this is the bokeh going into overdrive. Impressively I prefer the ROG Phone II in this shot, as the picture is very clear and crisp.
Position 6: Shopping Center
This photograph was taken under shade in an open-air shopping mall, with Christmas lighting all strung up and ready to go. We have the sun coming in from the right, shining on a set of walls but leaving a lot of the shot in the shade.
Mate 30 Pro | P30 Pro | ROG Phone II
For another scene, we have the P30 Pro being sharp, while the Mate 30 aims for more vibrant colors. In both cases, the floor is made very blue, whereas the ROG Phone, while not the most color vibrant shot, is probably the most true-to-life in most of the scene. Where the ROG Phone II falls short is the hanging lights, which both the Huawei’s depict quite clearly.
Position 7: Horse Statue
Another close up, this time of the shady side of a horse statue with the background containing a variety of Christmas lights.
Mate 30 Pro | P30 Pro | ROG Phone II
With the Mate 30 Pro again being hazy in the periphery, this does seem down to an over-active bokeh implementation. The shadows and marks of the statue are easier to make out on the P30 Pro, which actually feels the most true-to-life out of the three shots. The ROG Phone II here seems to add an AI filter here that doesn’t work, causing some miscoloration and a lot of blur on the Christmas lights.
75 Comments
View All Comments
Doc Rob - Monday, September 30, 2019 - link
the only reason I do not buy one of the ROG phones is simply I NEED wifi calling on tmobile.. I do no want to try and use other apps etc.. allow the use of voLTE and WIFI calling and it would open the market up for many more consumers.Kishoreshack - Tuesday, October 1, 2019 - link
Volte is enabled & WiFi Calling tooyou might have got wrong memo
TheinsanegamerN - Thursday, December 26, 2019 - link
Not in the USA it isntPeachNCream - Tuesday, October 1, 2019 - link
Alternatively, if you use Skype you can pay a fairly minimal amount of money to get a phone number and that will work both over WiFi and cellular data as a VoIP phone. It may fill your needs and mitigate the need for native WiFi calling support on the device.Kishoreshack - Monday, September 30, 2019 - link
@iancutress Where is the Display Analysis?Very sad you skipped on it
s.yu - Tuesday, October 1, 2019 - link
There's also a ton of mistakes in the spec sheet.It's 128/8GB or 1TB/12GB, there is no 256GB variant but there seems to be a 512GB one.
It's UFS3.0 not 2.1.
There are two C ports, which is highly unique but not noted.
Possibly other mistakes.
Death666Angel - Tuesday, October 1, 2019 - link
Probably some copy-paste issues in the table. And the second USB C port is mentioned on the first page below the picture of the connector.s.yu - Wednesday, October 2, 2019 - link
Yeah it was most certainly noted elsewhere, but the spec sheet should be comprehensive.Kishoreshack - Monday, September 30, 2019 - link
Why there is no display analysisNever seen Anandtech such an important aspect
Kishoreshack - Monday, September 30, 2019 - link
Ian Cutress you should have let Andrei do the display analysis or the review itselfhalf review is never expected from Anandtech