The Test: Performance What good is a product comparison without taking a look at the performance. These test are conducted using NetIQ’s Qcheck software which is designed for bandwidth and latency testing using typical traffic patterns instead of special “testing” packets (like ICMP).

The systems used:

Test Partner 1

Athlon 900 MHz
Windows XP Professional
Linksys HPN-200 PCI (Broadcom chipset)

Test partner for all HPNA tests.

Test Partner 2

Pentium III 450 MHz
Windows XP Professional
3com 905c PCI

Used for all bridge and router testing

Mobile Test Partner

Dell Inspiron 3700
Windows XP Professional

Used for all USB and PCMCIA testing

All tests were conducted using TCP transmissions of 1000KB. Each test was run six times and their results averaged. Wherever possible, we used the newest drivers and firmware for each of the devices.

We ran a battery of initial testing back in October, before the Cutting all Cables article to determine which of the HPNA products we had in the lab showed the strongest performance. Building on that, we chose the Linksys HPN200 PCI card to be a testing partner for the other stations.

This decision was made because the Broadcom chipset is very common, yet inexpensive and is the heart of a variety of HomePNA 2.0 devices. Also, our initial testing showed that devices based on the Broadcom chipset offered the highest performance. Other pairings were also tested to ensure there were no compatibility issues between the Linksys cards and other stations.

Linksys HPRO-200 Network Throughput
Comments Locked

0 Comments

View All Comments

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now