Conclusion

It is obvious that Das Keyboard tried to make the 5Q be as unique as a mechanical keyboard can be nowadays. Aside from it being the first "cloud-connected" mechanical keyboard, the company is also using proprietary mechanical switches that are exclusively available to them. The company’s point was to create a product that has no direct competition and, in a way, they have succeeded.

Generally speaking, the Das Keyboard 5Q is a very well-designed, reliable mechanical keyboard. Its design is deceptively unassuming, masking the advanced electronics and proprietary mechanical switches hidden inside the simple but elegant chassis. In terms of quality, we cannot voice even a single complaint.

The Omron-made Gamma Zulu switches left us with mixed feelings. They are very responsive, quick switches, with strong and quick recovery. These characteristics, along with the shorter travel distance, make the Gamma Zulu an excellent gaming switch. For professional use, however, the Das Keyboard 5Q is a bit more tiring than a keyboard featuring standard switches, tactile or not. Furthermore, the feeling of the Omron-made switches is mushy and the tactile feedback is hardly even noticeable. We would not go as far to say that the feeling resembles membrane-based switches but it may alienate people who were already used to other mechanical switches.

Das Keyboard’s idea of a cloud-connected keyboard certainly is innovative and, for the time being, unique to their top-tier keyboards. Although there is a learning curve for a user to be ready and take full advantage of the keyboard’s capabilities, the possibilities are virtually endless, especially for users with some API programming skills. Casual users can easily take advantage of the pre-programmed applets, which may be but a fraction of the keyboard’s full capabilities, but can be useful nonetheless.

The only problem here is that visual feedback from the keyboard is not really practical. This is especially the case when it comes to important notifications, as any notification can be easily missed if the user is not looking at the keyboard. Which due to the very nature of touch typing is usually going to be the case, and even more so for a high-end product like a Das Keyboard that's aimed at experienced typists (to say nothing of their unlabeled Ultimate boards). So while novel in application, it's not clear that visual notifications on a keyboard are going to be all that useful; at least not for time-sensitive notifications.

The utility of keyboard notifications then is a bit of a compromise: cloud-based feedback can be helpful, but probably only non-sensitive notifications, such as for weather forecasts. Conversely, I can't help but feel that a more traditional high-end keyboard that includes key programming and remapping would probbaly be much more useful for most users; professionals and gamers alike.

In summary, the Das Keyboard 5Q is an excellent quality mechanical keyboard, sporting the unique capability of connecting to the internet and taking advantage of cloud-based services. With a feature set no other keyboard can match, the 5Q stands out as a premium product for users that really want something different and/or find its cloud-based capabilities interesting. However its unique and cutting-edge features come with a $220 price tag, which is high even for a high-end keyboard. Ultimately this makes the Das Keyboard 5Q a niche product: if you like the idea of a keyboard that can provide visual notifications, then the 5Q is going to meet your needs nicely. But for typical professionals and/or gamers who aren't interested in the 5Q's niche features, a more traditional but equally-excellent keyboard can be had for a lot less.

Per-Key Quality Testing & Hands-On
Comments Locked

33 Comments

View All Comments

  • GNUminex_l_cowsay - Tuesday, February 26, 2019 - link

    This whole cloud connection thing sounds incredibly dumb. Like some executive decided they too have to jump on the internet of things bandwagon, not considering that:
    a) None of the functionality they added is actually keyboard specific, and really just amounts to a notifications app that runs on windows, but NOW makes a light blink on on your keyboard.
    b) They overlooked actual keyboard functionality in the form of key remaps and macros.
  • prophet001 - Tuesday, February 26, 2019 - link

    Yeah.

    You know what drives this stuff? The demand for sales.

    That's it.

    Sales. Have to sell.
  • close - Wednesday, February 27, 2019 - link

    "This theoretically sounds very interesting"

    No, no it doesn't...
  • milkywayer - Saturday, March 23, 2019 - link

    While I love my Das keyboard 4, I've decided not to buy one again just because I was quoted $50 plus shipping to fix a single f****** broken switch within the first year. The switch broke accidentally so the keyboard is reliable and I love it but I wish they had better support. You also get gimped warranty if you buy from Amazon directly. Gotta buy from Das keyboard store. Something they don't mention clearly.
  • justareader - Tuesday, February 26, 2019 - link

    I always wanted my own keylogger.
  • prophet001 - Tuesday, February 26, 2019 - link

    lol

    People are so ignorant of these things.
  • PeachNCream - Tuesday, February 26, 2019 - link

    Keyboards that phone home aren't a new thing. If you've ever installed an alternate on-screen keyboard on an Android and gotten the blaring warning message from Google saying that they won't be the only ones that might be able to creep over your shoulder while you send sordid text messages, you'd be a lot more comfortable with your PC having additional phone-someplace capabilities. It's a great time to be alive/harvested/bought-n-sold.
  • Azethoth - Tuesday, March 5, 2019 - link

    You are right, my mechanical keyboards on my iPad and iPhone have phoned home for forever now.
  • peevee - Tuesday, February 26, 2019 - link

    "most enthusiasts owning or wanting a mechanical keyboard nowadays"

    Do you have any proof for that?

    Don't fall to the typical modern "journalistic" standard of 100% fake news, please!
  • Death666Angel - Tuesday, February 26, 2019 - link

    He could just define "enthusiast" as "someone owning or wanting a mechanical keyboard". You are looking for hard facts where the wording itself is anything but hard. Also, this is not an academic paper or a serious publication dedicated to analysing political or scientific stances. Cool it a bit.

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now