Lenovo ThinkPad T410: Built for Business
by Jarred Walton on March 26, 2010 4:00 AM ESTLenovo ThinkPad Classic: Business Defined
Having put the latest ThinkPad T410 through its paces, we're hardly surprised by most of the results. ThinkPad has always been renowned for their build quality and durability, and the T410 is no exception. It may not look as stylish as other laptops (depending on your definition of style), but no business user would ever feel bad about carrying around a modern ThinkPad. If you're in the market for a business notebook (or if you run an IT department), you'd be remiss to skip the ThinkPad without at least testing a unit.
The ThinkPad Classic is understated yet powerful, with useful utilities to help get the most out of your laptop. The fact that our test unit is able to run under full load with an i5-540M CPU and still keep noise levels at just 33 dB speaks volumes about the engineering. Unlike laptops where the fans will oscillate between low and high RPMs, the T410 has a fan that's quiet but effective at idle and doesn't change speed unless you run heavy load, at which point the noise output roughly "doubles" (a change from ~30 dB to 33 dB). Even with such a potent CPU, the T410 never got more than moderately warm; certainly it's not a laptop that we would be uncomfortable putting on our actual lap.
Besides the excellent build quality—the T410 feels like it could travel around a lot and never skip a beat—our favorite part of the laptop is the keyboard. The feel of the keys is great, and after writing most of this review on the keyboard I can say without a doubt that it's the best laptop keyboard I've used in some time. I did notice that it tended to miss letters occasionally when I was typing fast, as it requires a bit more "force" for clicks to register (basically, you have to make sure to press the keys down far enough). After a few minutes I became more used to the keyboard and didn't have as many missing letters, and 4000 words later I can only wish more laptops would go with this style of keyboard rather than the attractive but less functional chiclet and flat key designs.
The one area where we wish Lenovo had done better is the LCD panel. We're happy to get the option of choosing a WXGA+ resolution (it's standard if you want the NVS 3100M GPU), and we like the matte surface, but higher resolutions don't inherently mean higher quality. The contrast ratio in particular needs help. We know that there are better panels out there—look at the ASUS 1001p or the Dell Precision M6500 for example, and there are plenty more—but such panels will obviously increase manufacturing costs. All we really want is at least a 500:1 contrast ratio, with a maximum brightness of at least 200nits; anything more (in contrast or brightness) is fine, but you definitely get diminishing returns. And whatever manufacturers do, please stop putting sub-200:1 LCDs in otherwise high quality laptops!
Ultimately, the decision often comes down to price, which is the one area where it's a bit difficult to give ThinkPads an explicit recommendation. The T410 is a wonderful laptop for a business user, and if your company is footing the bill then by all means, enjoy! If you're paying for the laptop yourself, you'll need to think a bit more about whether the extra features and build quality are worth $500 extra compared to consumer notebooks. In three years, that same $500 could be put towards a new laptop that would offer better performance than current systems. In fact, you could very easily buy two $800 laptops for the cost of a typical T410! Obviously, build quality doesn't come cheap.
The good news is that at least through the end of March, there's a great sale on the T410 and other ThinkPad laptops at Lenovo. A system similar to our test unit will run about $1275 right now, down from the regular $1720 price. That will get you 4GB DDR3 with the i5-540M and NVS 3100M, a 9-cell battery, Intel 6200 AGN WiFi, a fingerprint scanner, and a 2MP webcam that works better than most webcams we've tried. And unlike consumer laptops, short of outright abuse like dropping your laptop or spilling liquids on it, the T410 will probably last the next five years or more. If you've always wanted a ThinkPad but couldn't quite stomach the price, you might want to look at the current offerings.
If you're interested in other Lenovo products, we have a few other reviews lined up for the coming weeks. Testing is already well underway, so I can safely say that for me the ThinkPad T410 is my favorite of the bunch. Still, if you're looking for CULV alternatives, the IdeaPad 150/450p and ThinkPad Edge 13 reviews might be more your style, so stay tuned.
Facebook
Twitter
RSS
59 Comments
View All Comments
JarredWalton - Friday, March 26, 2010 - link
IdeaPad is definitely more for consumers IMO. As for HP business laptops, I've got an HP ProBook that I'm working on reviewing as well, so stay tuned to see how that compares. Unfortunately, determining reliability is a bit beyond the scope of a 30-day product evaluation, as they all tend to work well within that time period.strikeback03 - Friday, March 26, 2010 - link
By PSU do you mean the power brick? Because I know they changed the plug between the T43 and the T60.A note on the warranties: I don't know if they still have the site set up (my T43 went out of warranty a few yrs ago) but it is worth checking if they still track warranty periods by serial number. They at least used to have a site set up where you could check whether a certain system was still in warranty. Important if you are thinking of buying used or selling, no need to deal with receipts or anything, they track what coverage it has.
Part of the reason I have not upgraded is the loss of the Flexview screen. I love my 1400x1050 IPS screen, most don't match the resolution and I'm not sure any match the viewing angles.
DukeN - Friday, March 26, 2010 - link
Amen brother - can definitely say agree with everyone in there.I can not even fathom using another laptop after having a W500 and T61/T60 the last few years.
Great matte screens, standard power bricks and amazing build quality - no creaking, loose hinges or plasticky feels after years.
I wonder if the screen quality is noticeably improved in the W series, or the T410s.
Some great promos came out here in Canada in March, lots of folks bought really nicely outfitted T410s' for $1300ish after taxes.
ekul - Friday, March 26, 2010 - link
I had a thinkpad (T42) through my last employer and I miss it everyday. The keyboards are amazing, the hinges take any abuse you can offer, the thinkvantage driver program makes sure you always have the newest drivers and did long before windows 7, they are quiet and they are unobtrusive. Everyone I know who has used a thinkpad on a regular basis comes around to the conclusion they are the best.I spent nearly 4 years lugging that thinkpad around both my and client locations. It still looked like it had just come out of the box. It never put a foot wrong. Meanwhile, I had clients on their 3rd or 4th dell latitudes that had suffered various calamities from broken screens, dead motherboards to overheated cpus.
I almost forgot the absolute best feature. Standardized powerbricks means you can forget yours at home and IT has some spares sitting in their desk and it just works, regardless of what model you have. One of those features where once you need it you realize the brilliance of the engineer who fought for it.
jonup - Friday, March 26, 2010 - link
The function key is at the wrong place!We both a few R61 about two years ago and they had a superior hw than anything else in the office and they ran slow as hell. They were ugly, heavy and did I mentioned the function key? Thank god they got passed down to the staff so I do not have to hear the managers complaining about them all the time!
Xenoterranos - Friday, March 26, 2010 - link
There's actually an option in the BIOS to switch the functionality of the ctrl and fn keys. They'll still say fn and ctrl, but they'll operate they way their locations are supposed to!I bought this laptop after being disgusted with a compaq that literally disintegrated after only 2 years. Screws where falling out of the thing!
I replaced that with a cheap (500$) acer that barely lasted a year before the power plug broke off the motherboard.
For me, the deciding factor was the 3 year accidental damage protection for 160. (with student discounts). I got mine 20 days after they where announced :)
And for anyone wondering about thinkpad vs macbook build quality, you could probably bash a mac into pieces with a thinkpad, and still use the thinkpad afterward :)
jonup - Friday, March 26, 2010 - link
"both" should read "bought"takumsawsherman - Friday, March 26, 2010 - link
As a former fan of Thinkpads, I have to say that this unit seems like a big disappointment, though the review "sounds" positive, there are a lot of problems pointed out that make the laptop actually sort of "meh".In any case, in IBM's defense, not knowing about the new ones, if I need a part for the IBM thinkpad line, IBM is usually not only the quickest and best source, but also the least expensive. Case in point, a customer damaged their hearsink/fan assembly. Cheapest price for a replacement was IBM parts, who had it in stock (5 year old laptop) shipped it 2-day for about $68, and it came with screw hole covers (stickers) to replace any that lost their stick after replacement.
Now, Lenovo might have similar service, but the failure rate of the laptops that I see is way up (anecdotal, to be sure) and the quality is down. Of course, the same has happened with Toshiba, as they all race to the bottom. But IBM I always felt was more like Apple in putting quality over "low, low prices".
In any case, I think it would be crazy to buy this laptop. "The blah blah blah is wonderful for the business user". Business users should continue to switch to the much more pleasant MacBook Pro and throw VMWare on it if they need Windows. Then they can use the kick-butt snapshots, which you should be talking about, and talking to niche vendors about getting their dragging rears in gear to natively support the platform. This will help the business long term, and probably the Lenovos of the world as well. They shouldn't be able to count on the trapped consumer any more. They might even have to spend some time trying to improve the product.
Drag0nFire - Friday, March 26, 2010 - link
I actually think the T410 is fine for a 14 in chassis. The T510 (15 inch) is much less palatable competitor to the MacBook Pro. It actually comes in at 1.5in thick (and let's not even talk about weight)!Also of note, although the T410s was advertised with switchable graphics, Lenovo later dropped this feature.
I'm a long time fan of thinkpads, but I think the Lenovo is shifting in a very negative manner to respond to threats from "cheap" laptop manufacturers (Acer, Asus, HP). The T series used to be in the same category as the Macbook pro, a premium machine. The premium category is gone from the Lenovo line-up. You simply can't build the elegance of a 15in macbook pro for a base price of $800.
Belard - Sunday, March 28, 2010 - link
The R, T and above series have their roll-cages, its very much there. The weight and feature set is a bit better. And Mac keyboards are now standardized pretty-looking but awful looking keys (HP & SONY uses it). You can only get so thin... besides, the T510 is 1.4" thick including its rubber feet which are a bit thicker than apples.Lets compare pricing a features, basic:
Thinkpad T510: $1505 = Core i5 2.53Ghz / 4GB / 500GB HD / Win7 Pro / 15.6" LCD @ 1600x900 / Cam / blue-tooth / Wifi-N upgrade / WAN added with GPS function. 512mb Quadro discrete graphics (performs between 9400m & 9600m GT)
MacBook Pro 15" : $1950 = Core2 2.53Ghz / 4GB / 500GB HD / OS X / 15.4" LCD @ 1440x900 / Cam / Wifi N / blue-tooth / (no WAN) / 9400M - shares 256mb. (Less than half the Quadro NVS 3100m above).
$450 more... A CPU that is 1/3 slower, no WAN built-in, no discrete graphics. The ThinkPad T-510 can be had for under $1000 if I made it like the $1700 version of the iMac, but still with an i5 CPU. What I quoted for $1500 was a semi-top end model. I didn't make it 8GB or faster i5 CPU.
So this is Apples bottom end 15" notebook, but I changed the HD to 500GB and added the anti-glare screen ($50) as ThinkPads don't have stupid glossy screens. Funny thou, Apple charges $150 to upgrade the 320GB to a 500GB. Lenovo charges $80.... hmmmm.
If we upgrade the MAC 15" to the best...
MacPro 15" = $3300! Core2Duo 3Ghz / 8GB RAM / 500GB HD / Antiglare.
it would still be slower (CPU wise) than the $1000 T510.
T510 max: $2195 Core i7 620 2.66ghz / 8GB RAM / 500GB HD / WAN, etc.
I think I'd rather let apple keep that 0.45 " thinner body for that $1100 price difference.
Apple makes generally good products... I'd prefer to get something better for less.