System Performance: UL and BAPCo Benchmarks

Our 2022 Q4 update to the test suite for Windows 11-based systems carries over some of the standard benchmarks we have been using over the last several years. While UL's PCMark makes the list, we have opted to temporarily suspend reporting of BAPCo's SYSmark scores (pending fixture of the energy consumption aspect). Instead, BAPCO's CrossMark multi-platform benchmarking tool has been added to the set along with UL's Procyon suite. While CrossMark employs idle time compression and processes all workloads in an opaque manner, UL's Procyon processes real-world workloads with user interactions (like BAPCo's SYSmark). We have augmented the UL Procyon suite benchmark with our own custom energy measurement setup.

UL PCMark 10

UL's PCMark 10 evaluates computing systems for various usage scenarios (generic / essential tasks such as web browsing and starting up applications, productivity tasks such as editing spreadsheets and documents, gaming, and digital content creation). We benchmarked select PCs with the PCMark 10 Extended profile and recorded the scores for various scenarios. These scores are heavily influenced by the CPU and GPU in the system, though the RAM and storage device also play a part. The power plan was set to Balanced for all the PCs while processing the PCMark 10 benchmark. The scores for each contributing component / use-case environment are also graphed below.

UL PCMark 10 - Performance Scores

Discounting the DeskMeet B660, the GTR7 outscores the competition on the back of its lead in the productivity, gaming, and digital content creation workloads. The Essentials workload sees the Arena Canyon NUC enjoy a slight edge, but the sustained 65W configuration of the Ryzen 7 7840HS possesses way too much horsepower for the rest of the systems to match.

UL Procyon v2.1.544

PCMark 10 utilizes open-source software such as Libre Office and GIMP to evaluate system performance. However, many of their professional benchmark customers have been requesting evaluation with commonly-used commercial software such as Microsoft Office and Adobe applications. In order to serve their needs, UL introduced the Procyon benchmark in late 2020. There are five benchmark categories currently - Office Productivity, AI Inference, Battery Life, Photo Editing, and Video Editing. AI Inference benchmarks are available only for Android devices, while the battery life benchmark is applicable to Windows devices such as notebooks and tablets. We presents results from our processing of the other three benchmarks.

UL Procyon - Office Productivity Scores

The GTR7 manages a narrow victory in the Powerpoint workload, but the NUCs based on the Core i7-1360P emerge with slightly better overall scores.

From an energy consumption viewpoint, the 4nm fabrication process for the Ryzen 7840HS seems to help the GTR7. While raw performance scores see it slightly behind the Raptor Lake-based systems, the absolute values are fairly similar. However, the GTR7 gets the job done with minimal power consumption, and as a result, lesser overall energy consumption.

Moving on to the evaluation of Adobe Photoshop and Adobe Lightroom, we find the GTR7 coming out with a slightly better score compared to the systems using the Core i7-1360P. The flow utilizes some of the iGPU functionality, and the improvements in the Radeon 780M show up here along with the higher sustained power budget. Interestingly, the photo editing workload was the one that refused to complete with GPU drivers supplied initially by Beelink, but AMD's first public driver release for Phoenix resolved the issue.

UL Procyon - Photo Editing

The energy efficiency of the Phoenix SoC again comes to fore here, with the GTR7 being the most energy efficient by a huge margin.

UL Procyon evaluates performance for video editing using Adobe Premier Pro.

UL Procyon - Photo Editing

The GTR7 emerges as the best system among those not equipped with a discrete GPU. Its performance is within the realms of run-to-run variations with the souped up Core i7-1360P in ASRock Industrial's NUC BOX-1360P/D5.

On the energy front, the ability to get the job done fast helps in placing the GTR7 in the top half of the pack. The system comes second, falling slightly behind the ASRock Industrial NUC BOX-1360P/D5 with its CPU operating mode set to 'Performance' in the BIOS. However, similar to the raw performance scores, the gap is quite small.

BAPCo CrossMark 1.0.1.86

BAPCo's CrossMark aims to simplify benchmark processing while still delivering scores that roughly tally with SYSmark. The main advantage is the cross-platform nature of the tool - allowing it to be run on smartphones and tablets as well.

BAPCo CrossMark 1.0.1.86 - Sub-Category Scores

The use of idle time compression favors Intel-based systems, but that is not indicative of real-world performance. Based on these results, it would appear that scripting and automating workloads to keep the system busy all the time would probably be better on the Intel-based PCs. It is also possible that there could be BIOS tweaks and further tuning from Beelink to help the GTR7 perform better under such circumstances. Since CrossMark attempts to consolidate different workloads together without idle time intervals and play it back in a non-real-time environment, it is not entirely representative of real-world performance like PCMark 10 and UL Procyon. Therefore, tasks requiring frequent user interaction are better represented by those other benchmarks.

Setup Notes and Platform Analysis System Performance: Application-Specific Workloads
Comments Locked

56 Comments

View All Comments

  • darkswordsman17 - Friday, August 25, 2023 - link

    Apple doesn't need to pay anyone, nor would they have someone posting in such a manner even if they did, let alone on a niche PC tech website that's long past its glory days.
  • 1_rick - Thursday, August 24, 2023 - link

    "It's superior to this in just about every way."

    Not if I don't want to run MacOS.
  • StormyParis - Thursday, August 24, 2023 - link

    The 7840hs seems to be
    - on par for single-core work
    - 1.5 to 2x faster for multi-core
    - 1.5x faster for graphics
    - also it takes more and/or upgradeable RAM, storage, I/O, OSes...

    https://nanoreview.net/en/cpu-compare/apple-m2-vs-...
  • Gm2502 - Sunday, August 27, 2023 - link

    Are youj high, where in the world is a M2 faster then this 😂😂😂😂. All the benchmarks show this destroying M2 in every way, it can be upgraded, repaired and run windows. Another apple fanboy 😂😂😂
  • bsd228 - Monday, August 28, 2023 - link

    That 499 price is true for the basic model no one in their right mind wants, but the discount drops once you try to add on the other wants. The 16gb model is discounted 50, but that still makes it a $250 upgrade. If you want more disk, you're back to the 599 msrp plus the Apple charge. If you want 10gb over the weak 1gb, you're definitely paying msrp.

    The 5800u is a not quite at the 7840, but $350 for it with 32gb, 2x2.5gb and 500gb (replaceable) ssd is a much better docker box than the apple could ever hope to be.
  • BangkokTom - Tuesday, August 29, 2023 - link

    ...takes M2 mini apart, oh purposely bricked (this is a joke with Crapple's fix it yourself policy by the way)
  • sjkpublic@gmail.com - Friday, September 1, 2023 - link

    Ignore this person. Just a shil for the Apple monopoly.
  • Threska - Thursday, August 24, 2023 - link

    Kind of funny in a way. We've gone from obsessing with big computers to seeing how much computing we can squeeze into as small a space as possible.
  • 5080 - Thursday, August 24, 2023 - link

    Would be nice to see a build quality review and comparison between this and the SimplyNUC (Moonstone), Morefine (M600), and MinisForum (UM790 Pro) NUC's.
  • NextGen_Gamer - Thursday, August 24, 2023 - link

    Yes! Also, I really want these guys to release them barebones, so I can put in my own RAM/SSD (without wasting money on the included ones). I got in touch with Morefine, and they told me they are no longer releasing the M600 barebones and only as a full kit now (if you check their website, you see this is true).

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now