Stock Memory Performance

As discussed in earlier DDR2 memory reviews, the Intel platform does not really allow for easily testing different memory speeds at the same CPU speed. Instead most top motherboards provide a wide range of memory ratios that match available DDR2 memory. Most end-users can therefore select the memory ratio that matches their DDR2 memory speed. For those reasons, we first tested all of the stock ratios at the fastest stable timings we could achieve at the given ratio. With ratios, CPU speed remains the same at 3.46GHz in our memory test bed, and memory speed is varied by selecting different ratios.

OCZ EL PC2-8000 XTC (Stock Memory Ratios) - 2x1GB Double-Bank
CPU Ratio
at 3.47 GHz
Memory
Speed
Best Memory
Timings
(Voltage)
Far Cry
(fps)
Sandra
Unbuffered
Sandra
Standard
Buffered
SuperPi
Mod 1.4
2M places
(time in sec)
Half Life 2:
Lost Coast
(fps)
(4:3) 400
DDR2
3-2-2-6
1T 1.8V
61.5 INT 3001
FLT 3037
INT 5614
FLT 5608
87.6 75.6
(1:1) 533
DDR2
3-2-2-9
1T 2.1V
63.07 INT 3570
FLT 3600
INT 6500
FLT 6498
85.3 84.2
(4:5) 667
DDR2
3-2-3-10
1T 2.1V
63.07 INT 3999
FLT 3995
INT 6710
FLT 6691
84.7 83.4
(2:3) 800
DDR2
3-3-3-11
1T 2.1V
64.52 INT 4301
FLT 4356
INT 6774
FLT 6788
83 .3 81.7
(1:2) 1066
DDR2
4-4-5-14
1T 2.3V
64.38 INT 4576
FLT 4639
INT 6840
FLT 6843
82.1 81.2
*Rated Speed Overclocked
3:5 (300x13)
1000 DDR2* 4-3-4-12
1T 2.2V
64.75 INT 4982
FLT 5046
INT 7649
FLT 7654
72.9 95.2
Highest
Performance
Overclocked
3:5 (318x13)
1060 DDR2 4-3-4-14
1T 2.3V
75.06 INT 5260
FLT 5303
INT 8105
FLT 8107
69.1 96.7
Highest
Mem Speed
Overclocked
1:2 (275x13)
1100 DDR2 5-4-5-15
1T 2.35V
66.21 INT 4720
FLT 4785
INT 6952
FLT 6947
80.2 89.8


Since the OCZ PC2-8000 EL is rated at DDR2-1000, the 1000 speed was also tested. To achieve that speed the 889 memory speed was selected at the standard 1066 FSB (266 setting quad pumped). The FSB was then overclocked to 300 (1200 FSB) resulting in a memory speed of DDR2-1000. You can clearly see that the OCZ PC2-8000 EL performed much better than the rated timings of 4-4-5-15. Our testing found complete stability at DDR2-1000 at 4-3-4-12 timings.

In the introduction it was pointed out that the fastest possible timings with today's DDR2 are 3-2-2. If you look closely you will see the OCZ PC2-8000 works fine at the fastest timings that can be selected at both DDR2-400 and the 1:1 memory setting of DDR2-533. These are both the fastest timings we have ever been able to run with complete stability with DDR2. In fact all the way up to DDR2-1066 this new PC2-8000 memory sets new records for the lowest latencies we have found in testing DDR2 memory.

Despite the fact that CPU multipliers can not be dropped below 12X on the Intel platform, it is important to keep in mind that the first 5 table rows, from DDR2-400 to DDR2-1066, represent a constant CPU speed of 3.46GHz with memory running at faster speeds through ratios. 1:1 should always have the least overhead in the current Intel universe, but the DDR2 memory still scales well with speed over the full range. Memory bandwidth improves with memory speed, as does raw calculation performance. However, this does not always translate into linear gaming performance curves in Half Life 2: Lost Coast and Far Cry.

The PC2-8000 topped out at DDR2-1100, which is the fastest speed we have ever achieved with DDR2 memory. Timings were still a respectable 5-4-5-15. Performance was excellent at DDR2-1100, but it was not the fastest performance found in our testing. The distinction for fastest overall performance goes to the rated DDR2 speed of 1000. At that speed the CPU is running at 13x300 or a 1200FSB.

The memory at this speed is running a 3:5 ratio overclocked to 300 for a resulting DDR2-1000. At this speed memory timings are still a very aggressive 4-3-4-12 and this does influence the excellent memory performance we found in our benchmark suite.

While DDR2-1100 was within reach in our tests, memory timings of 5-4-5 were required for stability. We were able to achieve even higher performance at the fastest stable memory speed that could be achieved at 4-3-4 timings at a base 3:5 ratio (DDR2-889), This turned out to be DDR2-1060 at FSB of 1274. We included results for Highest Performance in the chart and used these highest performance settings in the charts for Best Performance (Highest Ratio). The system was 3D stable at 4-3-4 timings at DDR2-1067, and all benchmarks except SuperPi ran fine at 1067. SuperPi was unstable at settings above 1060 at 4-3-4 timings.

There are other possible approaches to overclocking DDR2 memory on the Intel platform. Probably the most logical, given the memory controller resides on the Intel chipset rather than the processor, is to look at overclocking at a 1:1 ratio. For our test setup that means a DDR2-533 base setting. You can see results of that approach on page 10.

Memory Test Configuration DDR2 400 (4:3) Performance
Comments Locked

16 Comments

View All Comments

  • plewis00 - Monday, April 3, 2006 - link

    If Half-Life 2 was producing anomalous results why didn't you replace it when you suspected a problem with some other game instead. Because haven't you now voided your HL2 benchmarks effectively?
  • Wesley Fink - Monday, April 3, 2006 - link

    The HL2 Lost Coast results were consistnet for this round of tests, but they did not compare well to earlier test results. We have now discovered the benchmarking issue and the HL2 results will be updated as soon as testing is complete.

    Earlier tests were run with HDR (High Dynamic Range) enabled, while current tests were run with HDR disabled. We are now testing with HDR enabled.
  • Avalon - Monday, April 3, 2006 - link

    You guys need to do something about those memory setting charts. The ones where you display the different timings you could achieve at different FSB settings for a particular memory...mainly, the part where you have "highest performance" I find misleading, because you have increased the CPU speed, so it almost makes it look like the performance results you have next to the settings are getting a huge boost in performance by going from one setting to the next, when it's really the CPU speed causing that.

    Maybe make a note on the chart stating that at highest performance mode, the CPU speed has been increased.

    Other than that, not a bad review. Good memory, it seems.
  • Wesley Fink - Monday, April 3, 2006 - link

    The information on which values were overclocked was already in the table, but we revised the chart to try to make the Overclocked values stand out more and to clearly identify the stock performance speeds and values.
  • SnoMunke - Monday, April 3, 2006 - link

    Interesting article...now about the grammar...

    "OCZ EL PC2-8000 is the best performing DDR2 memory we have ever tested, clearly outperforming any DDR2 that has been tested at AnandTech."
  • Wesley Fink - Monday, April 3, 2006 - link

    An edited sentence and the original sentence got accidentally combined. Thanks for pointing this out. It is now corrected.

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now