Any of our long time readers will know that I can have a soft spot for high-speed networking. Throughout the years I’ve been plagued with bad WiFi, irregular house shapes, routers that only come with a single 1G port, and the inability to set up a decent, cost effective high-speed home network. The movement to 10G has certainly been prevalent in the enterprise space, as shown by the growth of 10G panels at Supercomputing 2015 last year. However the movement to 10G for home use, which is still a niche category I admit, has been slow and still very expensive. Using 10GBase-T, over SFP or other connectivity, allows for backwards compatibility in the home which is still an important feature.

There are two main ways to show 10G to your home network: either pick up a NAS with 10G and use a switch with one or two 10G ports (then 10+ ports with 1G connections), or use a full 10G switch and have 10G devices. The cheapest 10GBase-T switch available for end-users is still Netgear’s XS708E 8-port switch, retailing for $750 or sometimes on sale for $625-650.

That’s around $80+ minimum per port for the switch, and then you need machines with 10G access. Depending on how the wind is blowing and what sales are on, single port PCIe cards with dual 10G ports can be had for $200-$220 on the gray market or up to $400 from source, with the main option of Intel controllers, however there are a few using an Aquantia/Tehuti networking solution. Or roughly translated, $100 per port, and it requires a system with a spare PCIe 2.0 x8 slot.

As we’ve previously reviewed at AnandTech, there are other options for having consumer-based 10G enabled systems. We reviewed the ASRock X99 WS-E/10G back in December 2014, which used a PLX PCIe switch to enable both the Intel X540T2 controller and four-way GPUs in a high-end motherboard. This motherboard currently retails for $770, and uses Haswell-E and Broadwell-E high-end desktop processors.

This motherboard held the title of the only consumer motherboard to come with a 10G chip for over a year. Late last year, in November 2015, ASUS met the feature half-way, offering their high-end Skylake-based Z170 Maximus VIII Extreme motherboard with a bundled single-port 10GBase-T card built on the Aquantia/Tehuti platform. The package carries the Extreme/Assembly branding, and also comes with a front panel DAC. We didn’t get time to review this bundle, and unfortunately the 10G card isn’t sold separately. The whole package is currently on sale for $570, however as it is Skylake based we are limited to a quad core i7-6700K system in this case.

Move forward to Computex 2016, and ASUS dropped on my doorstep the day before I left their new 10G motherboard design for Broadwell-E processors – a near final version of the product. This is the ASUS X99 E-WS/10G, their high-end desktop workstation motherboard with a built in Intel X550T2 controller for dual 10G ports. The board also comes with reinforced PCIe slots, support for U.2 drives, USB 3.1 and most of the updated modern features for a high-end product. We’re still in the process of testing and reviewing this motherboard, which is set for release sometime soon. Price unknown at this point, but we expect it to be certainly near the ASRock 10G board.

On the show floor at Computex, we saw another new entrant to the onboard 10G market on display. While all the other motherboards have been ATX (or E-ATX) so far, MSI is going to plug an Intel X550 controller on a Xeon grade Z170 micro-ATX motherboard to go after some smaller form factor designs. This design uses the C236 chipset, allowing users to equip either a Skylake Core CPU or a Xeon E3-1200 v5 processor, and siphons off four PCIe lanes from the CPU for the 10G controller. This gives 12 lanes from the CPU left, 8 of which go to the main PCIe slot, and another four to the M.2 slot as well. Being both Z170 based and micro-ATX should allow this product to be priced cheaper than the others, although unlike the others it only houses one 10GBase-T port rather than two. When MSI are near final with this motherboard, we’d love to get it in for testing.

There are also a variety of non-consumer focused motherboards with 10GBase-T ports, either with Xeon-D SoCs or dual socket motherboards, such as the MBD-X9DRE-TF+ from Supermicro (dual LGA2011) for $670 or the X10FRC-T4+-O (dual LGA2011-3) for $941.

For consumers looking to move to 10G for home networking, we’re still waiting for the pricing of switches to come down, however it would seem that there are moves afoot to equip more motherboards with 10G by default. There’s still the added cost, and it means the PCIe lane layouts might be a bit different to normal, but it removes the need for an extra PCIe slot/card overall. It’s a slow march, and the price of both switches and 10G controllers needs to come down to make it a more viable option.

 

POST A COMMENT

60 Comments

View All Comments

  • JoeyJoJo123 - Wednesday, July 20, 2016 - link

    The MSI MicroATX board is the most interest buy, for me at least.

    I've been really wanting to make a semi-mobile Twitch streaming PC/Server for console streaming, in a MicroATX case.

    It'd use two 1-slot PCI-e capture cards and a single RX480 (due to AMD's superior OpenCL capabilities and x.264's ability to offload some of the encoding work to GPUs, and the relative affordability of this card given that this isn't meant as a gaming PC).

    I'd have a Framemeister mounted onto the side panel, with a cutout for the DC barrel plug, and use a 6-pin from the PSU to a DC barrel plug adapter to actually power the Framemeister without an additional outlet. Game consoles could be plugged into the Framemeister and I could remote desktop into the computer at a friend's house to set up a high quality console gaming stream.

    Having a 10Gb NIC allows me to feel a bit more secure on using a MicroATX form-factor without feeling iffy on the lack of a 5th PCI-e port available for a multi-port NIC.
    Reply
  • nils_ - Friday, July 22, 2016 - link

    Maybe look at Server boards like Supermicro X10SRM-TF, it's micro ATX with 2x10GbE on board (Intel X550), 2x PCIe x8 and 1 PCIe x16. Reply
  • damianrobertjones - Wednesday, July 20, 2016 - link

    10GBe could be cheap now but, as is usually the case, they want to keep it there in order to max the $$$$ out of people. It's all about the $$$. Reply
  • pugster - Wednesday, July 20, 2016 - link

    The problem is 10ge switches costing $100 per port at least when gig switches cost around $2-3 per port. Not sure why consumers would jump to 10ge when they don't need the speed. Reply
  • alexdi - Wednesday, July 20, 2016 - link

    I upgraded my home network to 10GBe earlier this year. You can find dual-port 10GBase-T cards on the auction site for $150 or so. No switch, but perfectly capable of direct connection. I'm averaging 500 MB/s from my local SSD to my RAID-6 file server.

    Unless you're severely slot-constrained, it doesn't make much sense to get it as part of the motherboard. Better to buy the Intel X540 cards. They maintain a very high resale value. (Just don't buy the Chinese knockoffs; they often fail quickly.)
    Reply
  • JoeyJoJo123 - Wednesday, July 20, 2016 - link

    Basically this, and this is why the 10GbE port on the MSI MicroATX is a big plus, as opposed to the ~$700 ATX boards. Reply
  • nils_ - Friday, July 22, 2016 - link

    I would suggest looking at Mellanox Cards, they offer superior latency at a similar price point, and if you are doing direct connections you could also do 40-56GbE if you're crazy like me ;) Reply
  • pixelstuff - Wednesday, July 20, 2016 - link

    They just need to start putting these on every motherboard and be done with it. Go ahead and get that economy of scale to kick in. Reply
  • DParadoxx - Wednesday, July 20, 2016 - link

    No one wants something as expensive as 10GbE built into a motherboard they'll have to toss out at some point. Reply
  • melgross - Wednesday, July 20, 2016 - link

    I so t know how many people remember this, but in the days when Apple was pushing for higher wired networking speeds, they first made 100Mbs Ethernet standard on their machines, which immediately brought the cost down by almost 90%.

    Later on, they did the same thing with 1Gbs Ethernet. I remember the cards costing about $750, and right after Apple standardized them, it dropped to $150. It dropped way down a little more than a year after that.

    But Apple isn't interested in improving wired network speeds anymore with their push for wireless. It's disappointing.
    Reply

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now