Conclusion

The Meizu MX4 Pro is certainly an interesting device. There is no doubt that most readers will consider the most characterizing facet of the device the fact that this is a phone by a Chinese manufacturer who has yet to make a reputation for itself in the western markets. Trying to diverge from the well-known formula by employing a more radical customization of Android, Meizu nevertheless manages to put out a very solid product.

FlymeOS, while still lacking polish and distinguishing functional features, still manages to serve as a good OEM skin. The stock launcher is definitely the weak point but doesn't hinder the user from easily installing 3rd party software to get the application drawer back. I'm happy with Meizu's permission manager and see it as an important addition to the core OS that cannot be easily reproduced by other means. The interface is clean and the design language is attractive. Translation mishaps here and there are being progressively fixed by the continuous updates that the phone seems to receive since I got the sample unit. It's Meizu's services and ecosystem that need a more drastic effort as they completely lack even basic English support.

In terms of phone hardware, the MX4 Pro really seems to shine. The semi-metal build is extremely solid and gives an excellent premium feel to it, without having to sacrifice too much weight or texture due to the plastic back that in my opinion is well suited for the device. However, I miss the microSD card slot and given the device's internal build and I really wonder why Meizu chose to omit it.

Meizu's fingerprint sensor implementation works just as well as Apple's, and due to the dual-function as both mechanical home-button and capacitive function key brings a new way of navigation that, at least in theory, seems improved over previous Meizu models.

Meizu's choice of continuing with Samsung's line of SoCs is no disadvantage compared to the competition. The Exynos 5430 will probably remain as the most power efficient SoC of the existing A15 generation. A57 SoCs are just around the corner and one may question the choice of going forward with the purchase of a last-generation architecture device, but I've proven that in terms of perf/W the Exynos 5430 leads the newer generation 5433. Unfortunately, the raw performance of the SoC is often wasted by poor software optimizations in the OS. If you're running non-native applications, you might not see the full potential of the hardware. I hope an eventual Lollipop update will fix these issues.

It's on the GPU side that performance may not be totally satisfactory due to the Mali T628MP6. Here a more robust GPU such as the Adreno 420 found in the Snapdragon 805 would have been a better fit for the QHD screen.

When it comes to the MX4 Pro's display, the 5.46" JDI panel is a double-edged sword. Delivering excellent maximum brightness and amazing low-light night reading modes at the same time, and the outstanding sharpness of the 1536p 546PPI resolution, are feats that could be overshadowed by the inaccurate and oversaturated colors of the default calibration that Meizu decided to employ. In terms of screen size, I think Meizu hit the upper limit of the sweet-spot for one-handed use as the sloping sides make for a very comfortable one-handed grip of the phone.

The choice of SoC, efficient display, and a large 3350mAh battery make for remarkable battery life on the Meizu. Gaming may get a little bit hot due to the GPU, but other everyday usage easily competes with top-performing devices.

The camera performs well, but don't expect it to quite reach the quality of OIS contenders such as the G3, Note 4, or iPhone 6 Plus. Compared to what the Huawei offered in the Honor 6 and Mate 7, there is however a noticeable improvement in quality.

A big detractor is the cellular network support. If you live in North America, you will not get LTE support. Europeans will be more lucky to see either 1800 or 2600MHz band support on their carriers. Until Meizu specifically targets a model with more global band support, this will remain a unit that is best served on the Chinese mainland. It is a pity as the Marvell modem seems to behave quite well in my subjective usage.

When it comes to deciding whether the MX4 Pro is worth buying, again it comes down to price. The device can be found through various web-shops internationally starting at $499 or ~380€ for the 32GB model, with the 16GB going for even less. I think Meizu hits a reasonable performance/price level that makes the MX4 Pro a more attractive choice than competing devices at its level. The Nexus 6 and Mate 7 both under-perform in everything but software and sheer screen size, while the Note 4 or iPhone 6 vastly out-price the Meizu putting them in a different category. Overall, if you can make due with the LTE bands, I think the MX4 Pro is a solid phone that is worth considering.

Camera - Still Pictures and Video performance
Comments Locked

70 Comments

View All Comments

  • aryonoco - Monday, February 16, 2015 - link

    As much as I appreciate your in-depth analysis of SoC, power usage and displays Andrei, your taste in UI really baffles me.

    That is the most hideous, disjointed, inexplicably redundant UI I have ever seen on an Android device, and you seem to like it. I'm simply astounded that you like this everything-and-the-kitchen-sink approach that many Chinese OEMs employ in regards to their ROMs. Brian and Anand knew that every additional UI feature comes with a cost, and it's a matter of finding the sweet spot. This point seems to be totally lost on you.

    As an occasional Android developer, I would hate to think what Play Store reviews would look like if phones like this, with their ability to revoke permissions from apps and for users to break apps without realising that they have done so, would look like. Thankfully, no OEM which actually provides customer care support is going to implement this in a Western country, as the support cost is going to be enormous.

    I really don't mean to sound disrespectful, but I'd love for Andrei to limit himself to hardware discussion in future Android devices (in which he is extremely skilled), and leave the UX review for someone with a bit more, shall I say, taste
  • Andrei Frumusanu - Monday, February 16, 2015 - link

    I'm reviewing for the user, not for the OEM. In my opinion Android suffers a lot from Adware and misbehaving apps that such permission managers are a pure benefit to the user as already commented by some others here.

    I have experience in software UI design and user interaction, so while you might disagree with me I see plenty of other people who find Meizu's new UI equally attractive.
  • overseer - Monday, February 23, 2015 - link

    To me Flyme OS has a homescreen with icons ugly as Quasimodo's face and so 2010, but the rest of interfaces (settings, notifications, etc) look strangely okay and taste somewhat close to Lollipop. This is a huge disparity in design practices and keeps me wondering if Meizu's UI designers hold a paranoiac love over that homescreen or they kind of hit a temporary ceilling in their professional competency. I would've taken the plunge for MX4 months ago had I not seen their everlasting homescreen. *_*
  • samflorin - Tuesday, February 17, 2015 - link

    @aryonoco cm11S for One+ called, would like a word on the built in permission manager.
  • ffsmaster - Tuesday, February 17, 2015 - link

    It is a pity that this review does not include the audio system: ES9018K2M+OPA1612.
  • Andrei Frumusanu - Tuesday, February 17, 2015 - link

    I just didn't have anything to write about it. It sounds good? Without proper equipment as in the iPhone 6 review audio testing has become futile.
  • vanguardkl - Wednesday, September 28, 2016 - link

    This. I'm coming back here in Sept 2016 just to say this. This phone is 1.5 years old - has a 2k screen. HD HiFi audio DAC - most people have to spend $100 just to buy this separately - among the best specs seen on any phone - and costs $150 now. I'm buying one as soon as I can - there's nothing that comes close to this value. This phone is a diamond in the rough, and once people know about its gonna be snapped up.. Hopefully this comment stays in the dirt. I have a Meizu M1 Note which I got for $125 and its next to perfect with 1080p screen and all. They provide MONTHLY updates to the OS and improvements all the time. Amazing I'm so happy with Meizu and hopefully they remain buried under the news headlines and I can pick up these phones for cheap.
  • loimlo - Thursday, February 19, 2015 - link

    Nice job! Well-written review!! How about other Chinese vendors like Xiaomi, Oppo, Vivo ?
    I've been using Redmi for a year and am very fond of it. Solid HW/SW given its humble pricing.
  • Hrushi - Thursday, August 6, 2015 - link

    It is surprising to see that anandtech have missed on detailed audio quality analysis even when device have boasted this feature.
  • inguru - Thursday, July 21, 2016 - link

    Brother if you are really considering this to buy please be sure. Coz if something happens you cant fix this one. They have this digital security locked to its mainboard which you will not able to overwrite. No flashtool no ADB no fastboot what ever you try it will never be fixed & they are very dictating by saying send the phone to them but at the time you will b out of warranty and no place you will be able to go to bring it back. Its a dictatorship company. Be aware... you will never want to be in this situation

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now