It's an iPod Dammit

The one aspect of the iPhone that still hasn't sunk in for me is the fact that this thing is actually an iPod.  Inevitably the majority of attention has been placed on the phone/internet aspects of the iPhone, while its ability to be an iPod has been relegated to a casual mention in passing.  But the iPhone is quite capable of replacing your iPod, provided that you're not dependent on having more than 8GB of music with you at all times.  True music aficionados will still hang on to their iPods, but the iPhone is designed for the crowd with slightly less music who love their iPods but hate carrying two devices around.  If you carry your iPod around everywhere, the iPhone should be quite tempting as it helps reduce pocket clutter. 

The iPod + phone meld not only makes sense, but it's done well on the iPhone.  About the only thing that's missing is the ability to assign your MP3 files as ringtones.

The classic iPod interface is changed, having been replaced by something that conforms better to the iPhone UI.  Playlists are obviously still supported, as is the ability to create a playlist On-The-Go. 

You can browse music according to artists, songs, albums, composers or genres.  You can even customize the menu at the bottom of the iPod screen to give you direct access to audiobooks or podcasts.  The one thing that I'm really missing that's present in iTunes on the Mac/PC is the ability to type and search by name for a song/artist/album.   


Viewing all the tracks on an album gives you this slick interface, the slider at the bottom controls volume

Tilt the iPhone on its side and you get a layout of album covers to flip through, much like you would at a record store, if you'd like to listen to an album in particular.  If you have a lot of music that's unreleased (or poorly pirated), you'll be greeted with a bunch of blank album covers which ruins some of the beauty of this feature. 


This would look cooler if everything had album art

There doesn't seem to be a full hold mode on the iPhone; while hitting the sleep/wake button will prevent you from accidentally hitting anything on the screen, the volume rocker is still active. 

Thankfully the iPhone has a volume limiter that you can engage to prevent you from accidentally ruining your hearing while listening to music with the iPhone in your pocket. 

The speaker on the iPhone, while well suited for voice conversations, is not great for listening to music.  It's functional but prepared for distortion-a-plenty, you're better off sticking to headphones.

The earbuds that come with the iPhone are a standard set of iPod headphones with a mic/button about 5 inches below the right earbud.  If you're listening to music when you get a phone call, the iPhone will automatically fade out and pause your music so that you can answer your call (just click the button on the headphones).  Click the button again to hang up and you're back to your music. 

When I first went to try video playback on the iPhone I was lost, I kept looking around for a video player until I eventually remembered that the iPod button was all encompassing - audio and video seekers can find refuge there.  The video formats supported by the iPhone are the same as the iPod and Apple TV, you're basically limited to low bitrate H.264/MPEG-4 files, both of which Quicktime Pro will encode for you.  The iPhone is in dire need of DivX/XviD support, but that's something Apple will never do, so either plan on converting anything you want to watch to H.264/MPEG-4 or wait for someone to hack this thing. 

Videos look great on the iPhone and as a whole, it puts competing devices to shame.  While both the Blackjack and Blackberry can play MP3s and videos neither has the storage or interface of the iPhone, they are functional but not nearly as well done as a dedicated iPod or in this case an iPod within the iPhone. 

Wireless Networks: Edge, WiFi and Bluetooth Pictures
Comments Locked

85 Comments

View All Comments

  • CaptainDDL - Monday, July 2, 2007 - link

    Could you take a picture of what the iPhone shows when you're trying to connect to a secure Wi-Fi connection? Thanks.
  • slashbinslashbash - Monday, July 2, 2007 - link

    Love the Group X reference.

    And once again Anand reminds me why I read Anandtech and don't really visit any other tech sites. He covers everything I want to know in a way that other reviewers can't.

    It's strange but I guess understandable that the iPhone doesn't use AIM/iChat/etc. AT&T (and any other carrier for that matter) would rather not have the iPhone than give up the lucrative SMS plans. But I doubt it will be long before there's a web-based AJAXy AIM client that will run beautifully on the iPhone and only use the data plan, not SMSes.
  • Anand Lal Shimpi - Tuesday, July 3, 2007 - link

    I'm glad people got the reference and didn't just think that there was something horribly wrong with me :)

    I don't want a web based AIM client, I want AIM support from Apple in the same fashion as SMS support on the iPhone. Dammit Steve, you know it'd be awesome.

    Take care,
    Anand
  • Zirconium - Monday, July 2, 2007 - link

    I don't want Apple's iPhone, I just want BANG BANG BANG!!!
  • frank5592 - Monday, July 2, 2007 - link

    get to top of web page by double tapping the gray top menu bar

    Very helpful for long web pages

    Great review, very impressive work and by far the best review of the iphone

    BTW, typing this on iphone safari and noticing that predictive typing is some what slow and does not always show up
  • Anand Lal Shimpi - Tuesday, July 3, 2007 - link

    Thanks for the tip and the comment, I've updated the review :)

    Take care,
    Anand
  • Chaotic42 - Monday, July 2, 2007 - link

    Seriously, this was an *excellent* review. I don't even have a cell phone and I couldn't have cared less about the iPhone before I read this, but I was bored. This answered every question that I or anyone I've talked to about the phone has had, and it was a great read. It makes me want one now.

    *Very* well done, Anand.
  • Anand Lal Shimpi - Tuesday, July 3, 2007 - link

    Thank you so much for your kind post, there's no better feeling than pouring a lot of work into an article and getting a response like that. Thanks again :)

    Take care,
    Anand
  • Dennis Travis - Tuesday, July 3, 2007 - link

    Agreed, your iPhone review was totally outstanding. You covered everything and then some and took the time to explain each feature in a way that anyone can understand.

    Another great review Anand. Told me everything I wanted to know about the iPhone.

  • michael2k - Monday, July 2, 2007 - link

    It sounds like you will want an iPhone if:
    1) You have $600
    2) You like the iPod
    3) You like Star Trek: The Next Generation

    The only thing missing is voice recognition! And flexible roll up displays.

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now