OSD

Usually, we benchmark all others on screen displays against Samsung, perhaps solely due to Samsung's lack of real competition concerning interfaces. However, after recently switching most of our lab monitors over to 1702FP LCDs, Dell became our new favorite.



With the introduction of the Dell 2001FP, the input controls have been consolidated while the menu has been expanded. The newest additions are in the PIP and Audio/Video control features. The AV controls are just controls for how to manipulate the video and audio channels when the monitor is on standby. This is something the Albatron L17AT lacked and received criticism for in our review. The PIP controls are a bit more interesting. While you cannot put a VGA and a DVI signal into split screen (a limitation of the gm1601 Malibu), we can manipulate just about every option for the PIP, including brightness, size and contrast. Again, another great feature since video coming in over the composite cable can sometimes be dark or inaccurate.

Unfortunately, auto calibration on the 2001FP left something to be desired. Whether an added “feature” or simply a signal in the gm1601 processor, the monitor is designed to auto adjust when switching between display modes. This is great if you are switching between a game and email or vice versa. However, the (in)accuracy of the auto adjust makes this more of a nuisance than anything. When going from a full Windows environment to the splash screen for Max Payne 2, the monitor crops the image almost 400 pixels off the side of the screen. This sounds incredibly familiar to another LCD based on one of Genesis' chips.


Click to enlarge.


Above, you can see the image cropped off the screen by about 80 pixels, even though we are running Microsoft Word in full screen. Hopefully, retail models will have this addressed a bit better. Further aggravation comes from the inconsistency of the calibration. Running the auto adjust three or four times can result in a differently aligned image each time. Even though we are beating a dead horse, the screen brightness is also adjusted via the auto adjust. This is also inconsistent and we would prefer if Dell would just leave that part of our monitor alone.

On a cheerier note, this LCD let's you “zoom” in or out on a signal. Want to run a 1024x768 game without any pixel interpolation? Simply zoom out on the signal and you will have the 1024x768 box in the middle of the screen. Counter Strike addicts rejoice!


Click to enlarge.


Another neat feature we would like to comment on is the one button input selection on the front of the monitor. Who wants to go into the menu just to switch between S-Video and DVI? All in all, while we are impressed with the interface as a whole (good navigation, input control, PIP, zoom), the auto adjust pulls unnecessarily our total impression of the OSD down.

Genesis gm1601 Malibu Power Consumption
Comments Locked

53 Comments

View All Comments

  • miomao - Tuesday, November 11, 2003 - link

    marcst
    The new NEC 2080UX+ (note the "plus") has the same panel of the Dell 2001FP.
    :)
  • KristopherKubicki - Monday, November 10, 2003 - link

    Its the same thing. :) So in a way, you have the new champ ;)

    Kristopher
  • marcst - Monday, November 10, 2003 - link

    Before pronouncing the 2001FP as "new big LCD champion", you should really have a look at the NEC 2080UX, 1600x1200, S-IPS-Panel. Really awesome panel, and not a single annoying dead pixel/subpixel (my panel)!
  • KristopherKubicki - Monday, November 10, 2003 - link

    We tested with a 9800 Pro. Sorry about the mixup.

    Kristopher
  • miomao - Monday, November 10, 2003 - link

    No CRT is sharp as LCD...
    and for color next years we will have 30bit colors LCDs.

    Remember Sony will stop Trinitron production in 2004!

    The main issue of LCD will remain fixed resolution.
  • wicktron - Monday, November 10, 2003 - link

    it's improbable for lcd's to ever match the color accuracy and sharpness of a crt.
  • ripdude - Monday, November 10, 2003 - link

    neat article.

    I still find the performance of (any) LCD unrewarding for its price. Until LCD's are on the same quality as CRT's I'm not trading in my 17" CTX :).
  • Slingman - Monday, November 10, 2003 - link

    Great article Anandtech! I know a lot of us were waiting for a good review of the new LG panel. My only question would be in regards to how it compares to the Samsung 213T? I believe this to be every bit as competitive as the 192T is, especially considering it runs at 1600x1200, just like the 2001 FP does. Granted, it is more expensive, but many of us will use it as a basis of comparison when shopping for a new 20"+ display.

    Before knocking the review for their comment on DVI, one should have their facts in line. All the newer video cards on the market, in particular the newer Radeons and Geforce FX's, support 1600x1200 on the DVI interface. You do not need a pro-level card in order to do this.
  • mcveigh - Monday, November 10, 2003 - link

    can't remember where I saw it but 9800 series does it I believe
  • Shalmanese - Monday, November 10, 2003 - link

    What video card did you test this with? To the best of my knowledge, consumer grade cards only support 1280x1024 on DVI. You need a fairly expensive pro card if you ever want to use 1600x1200 on DVI which makes it rather flippant to recommend that people can ignore the VGA issues and use DVI instead.

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now