Battle of the Budget Tablets - Nook Color vs. Galaxy Tab
by Vivek Gowri on May 25, 2011 12:52 AM ESTRound 2 - Usability
This is an interesting one. We have two screens here that have the same resolution, but really don’t feel like it. One of the things that Samsung did with the TouchWiz UI on the Galaxy Tab is that they made all of the UI elements a lot bigger. It’s like taking Windows and changing the DPI of the icons to 120 or something. Side-by-side with the unchanged Nook Color, you almost feel like the screen resolution is significantly lower, until you put the same image or website on both.
It’s not a good thing or bad thing, it’s just different. I personally liked having the smaller icons on the Nook, but at the same time, the Galaxy had a larger keyboard that was easier to use, so it was a bit of a tradeoff.
The Galaxy was smoother to use than the Nook; the same stuttering and lost frame issues I saw in Nook OS were still there in Gingerbread. I’ve heard that a lot of that can be fixed through overclocking, installing different launcher applications, and the like, but I wanted to get a feel for how a quick root would be. And overall, I must say it was pretty good. I enjoy the stock Android UI, especially in Gingerbread. It’s a refreshing experience compared to some of the things that Motorola, Samsung, and HTC tend to do to Android.
With that said, there are still some bugs. I ran into a weird one where I locked the device, came back 10 minutes later, and the phone-menu-browser launcher at the bottom had somehow lost the phone and browser buttons. Not that I necessarily minded, since the phone part of it was completely useless to begin with. The weird part was that after I ran the battery life test and rebooted the device, the application menu button was gone too. Another lock/unlock fixed that, but it’s a little weird. Unfinished, probably, would be the best way to describe it.
Which is how most of these community projects go - if you follow the nightly builds closely, I’m sure a lot of these little things will be fixed. If you’re not on top of those things, you just have to learn to deal with those issues.
I did like that the Android community had seen fit to give the Nook ROM software buttons for menu and return (located in the right corner of the top bar in Android), but the lack of hardware buttons wasn’t necessarily optimal. You get used to it, yes, but compared to the Galaxy, it just feels unfinished.
Honestly, I like the stock Gingerbread ROM better than anything running TouchWiz, but for lack of polish, I think I’ll give Samsung the small victory here too.
Facebook
Twitter
RSS
89 Comments
View All Comments
Pessimism - Wednesday, May 25, 2011 - link
I'd LOVE to see a roundup review of all the offshore generic pad clones you listed off at the start of the article.VivekGowri - Wednesday, May 25, 2011 - link
Yeah, so would I, but I'm not going to hold my breath for review units - I'm still waiting on eLocity, Archos, and NotionInk.peldor - Wednesday, May 25, 2011 - link
My wife uses the rear-camera on her 3G Galaxy Tab all the time for facebook posts (and as you note, it's good enough for that).The $200 Tab at Verizon with a $20 data plan (1GB/mo I think) was the cheapest way to get her an Android device with mobile service. She loves it.
Also note, Kindle slipcases are a very good fit for the Tab.
cgalyon - Wednesday, May 25, 2011 - link
I've always been a fan of the Nook Color, it's just a great little device (largely thanks to the hacking of it). One little thing that I think makes a large difference (and isn't mentioned in the review) is the distance from the screen to the glass. The Nook Color's screen is very close to the glass (like on the Palm Pre). This just has a nicer feel to it, but it's a subtle difference.That said, I ended up getting a Galaxy Tab 3G (refurb at $260). Seems like an unbeatable deal.
smolten - Wednesday, May 25, 2011 - link
http://www.woot.com/The price difference is GONE! You can get a refurbed Galaxy Tab off of WOOT today only for 259.99!
Samsung Galaxy Tab 7" 16GB Android Tablet - Wi-Fi + 3G
$259.99
* + $5 shipping
Condition:
Refurbished
Product:
1 Samsung Galaxy Tab 7" 16GB Android 2.2, Wi-Fi + 3G (Sprint), microSD, BT, GPS, 3.0 & 1.3MP Cams
micksh - Wednesday, May 25, 2011 - link
in order to install CM7 to eMMC. So the process of installing a custom ROM a bit more complicated but still doable.vld - Wednesday, May 25, 2011 - link
Why wouldn't you include the Archos 101 Internet Tablet in the <$300 collection?smolten - Wednesday, May 25, 2011 - link
Archos 101 is completely garbage! My screen was damaged in one week after I got it. The resolution is horrible as well. The replacement device I got was brand new and when you clicked on the screen it would register someplace else. Avoid the Archosits cheap and horrible.
,
skyhawk21 - Wednesday, May 25, 2011 - link
Curious why the author of this article did not include an audio section to compare whichever version of the Samsung Galaxy Tab to the Barnes & Noble Nook Color?Nook Color:
* Mono speaker installed into back of Nook Color tablet faces backward
* Volume at loudest is mediocre at best
* For some reason audio channels are reversed through the stock firmware when using headphones
* Headphone port has noticeable static in background even with audio muted
* Headphone port not solid and has trouble inserting a 3.5mm cable
Galaxy Tab:
* Stereo speakers installed into bottom of tablet face downward
* Volume at loudest is noticeable
* Audio channels are correct
* Headphone port has no static present in background when audio is muted
* Headphone port is solid and handles 3.5mm cables firmly
- Also I do believe the original galaxy tab natively will play 720p videos smoothly and has a full complete working android market. You can play 1080p videos with third party android software
- Even with a rooted nook color the market has issues, applications have issues due to not finding a hardware GPS built in so those apps will not load. Also battery drain and sleep issues are present with the different third party firmwares available. Nook color has many issues with using 802.11 N mode WIFI with many routers.
- Original Galaxy Tab stock do not have any of these issues present!
I did not see this information in the article so I thought I would post it!
VivekGowri - Wednesday, May 25, 2011 - link
I never had any issues with the headphone jack on the Nook, though I agree the speaker is terrible. Also, I found Market to work pretty well on the Nook...all of the apps I tried worked fine, but I didn't do much as far as location-centric apps because I knew there wasn't GPS on the device.