AT&T 3G MicroCell: A Comprehensive Exploration
by Brian Klug on April 1, 2010 1:55 AM EST- Posted in
- Smartphones
- AT&T
- Microcell Review
- Mobile
Performance - Data With Multiple Devices
In location 1, I used two iPhone 3GSes to show how easily that HSDPA 3.6 Mbps can get saturated:
Look at Download - This is location 1 right next to the microcell
If you add up the downstream speeds, you can see how close we are to that real-world 2.2 Mbps effective limit of 3.6 Mbps HSDPA. That's the performance limitation, not so much the internet connection. Both phones went on to reflect the capped 60 Kbps of upstream that's strictly enforced. Two devices is fair enough, but this is AnandTech, let's take it four devices - the MicroCell's limit - and see how things fare then.
A plethora of phones? Either way, it's enough to make AT&T sweat.
The MicroCell handles the limit of four devices perfectly fine, all four phones joined the femtocell in under a minute after moving into the coverage range. Simultaneous data across all four is doable, but not ideal. It's very obvious there's additional overhead. I did notice what I can only describe as occasional glitchiness, getting all four tests to run at the same time was just a bit challenging. This is likely the iPhone's tendency to break data connections and reestablish them only when needed to preserve battery rearing its head.
For these tests, I ran speedtest.net at the same time on all the phones and averaged the results across the phones. Again, we can see the very obvious upstream cap of around 60 Kbps.
Performance doesn't scale linearly, and again in location 2 I wasn't in the room where the MicroCell was, I was a few rooms away. The biggest thing I can take away is that if you've got internet at your home or small office where you're installing the MicroCell, you've probably got WiFi too. At that rate, just use WiFi for data, and only tax the MicroCell with voice and SMS.
Facebook
Twitter
RSS
63 Comments
View All Comments
leexgx - Friday, April 2, 2010 - link
the UMA thing looks good idea, seems Way more piratical then these base stations ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generic_Access_Networ... ) only ever seen it on blackberry phones thought, only issue i could see with them is if it doe snot work with the wireless router correctly or intermittently out of range of routerjulioromano - Friday, April 2, 2010 - link
Very nice and geeky review.Thanks for all the infos!
Simozene - Friday, April 2, 2010 - link
1. These units need to be very cheap or free for consumers.2. Any minutes or data usage that is routed over this instead of AT&Ts regular network should not be counted towards the limits on your data plan. It's not their network so you should not have to pay for using it.
If those two conditions are met I can see how this could be a very useful product.
sxr7171 - Friday, April 2, 2010 - link
But it's not. It can't even hand off properly.Chrisg331 - Friday, April 2, 2010 - link
1st off, great article. Good methodology as well. Will you be able to test different handsets (Primarily different chipsets/antenna designs to eliminate bias on the dropped calls), possibly test a repeater (as mentioned before) and possibly test data usage pattern(s) for those that may be bandwidth capped on their broadband? Great job. Could really be useful to those looking to ditch landlines.GregHH - Friday, April 2, 2010 - link
In your haste to slam AT&T you neglect to notice that the other cell carriers offer the same type of device. That implies their coverage must not be perfect and all encompassing. Everyone seems to think cell coverage should be ubiquitous whether in a metro area or in the wilderness. I feel good that my area finally got 3G coverage in December of 2010.JKflipflop98 - Saturday, April 3, 2010 - link
So, we're in the future looking back on the past then? Or we're in the past looking towards the current? Oh God, my head's going to explode.ivwshane - Friday, April 2, 2010 - link
There is no required monthly cost. Buy just the microcell and use your existing minutes and data plan. Buy a microcell with a $20 feature and you can have unlimited minutes while using it and you also get a $100 rebate.No one is forcing anyone to buy these, at&t is simply giving it's users a choice, if you want to improve your in home coverage then buy one, otherwise don't.
mikeshady - Saturday, April 3, 2010 - link
So if I understand it correctly the price,$20/month unlimited calling$10/month with AT&T DSL
$0 with AT&T landline.
Will i be able to use it for the unlimited free since i have att landline
mrSHEiK124 - Tuesday, April 6, 2010 - link
Those failed handover videos; that happens ALL OF THE TIME on at&t in the Tampa, FL area. If you're on a highway or main-road and venture off into the boonies, as you get booted off 3G all you can hear is distortion (the handover is successful and the call doesn't drop, but good luck continuing the phone call...) and weird audio artifacts. at&t...more bars in more places.