So...what do you all think?

Any and all comments/feedback are appreciated, I'll post more about the new site later tonight/tomorrow morning - I'm just testing out the blog posting functionality right now :)

Take care.
Comments Locked

132 Comments

View All Comments

  • NiLe - Tuesday, July 6, 2004 - link

    I kind of liked the old one better. I often read this page on my smartphone and the old page was perfect with a lot of news right on the frontpage. I know you've added a mobile section, but as a third alternative you could just have a textpage with brief news like the lower part of the old layout. The old page was <30k if you disabled images so it was perfect for handhelds.

    Anyway, this is still the number one HW page, Thanks for all great articles.
  • GhandiInstinct - Tuesday, July 6, 2004 - link

    Ever consider a "Ask Anand" section in the forums? People that don't get their questions quite answered can ask the master, chief. Hmmm?
  • Kaji - Tuesday, July 6, 2004 - link

    not enough articles on the front page. 4 would be cool. I just get the feeling that if you're not fast, you might miss a good article, cause it would have to move off the front page to make room for newer articles. Then it would get lost in all of the links somewhere.
  • anshul - Tuesday, July 6, 2004 - link

    liked the old layout better - this one is better for newbies to anandtech who maybe visit once a fortnight or something.

    this is daily bread for me - so i want to see the descriptions of the major reviews/articles as opposed to just descriptions for 2 and titles for the rest.

    the width too should be lesser - i'm on 10x7 but i keep my taskbar aligned to the left instead of the bottom - so i have to do left/right scrolling.
  • Cliff - Tuesday, July 6, 2004 - link

    Sadly i'm in with the majority here too...the old site was much more crisp and very easy to see the content. I feel like i'm watching commercials instead of visiting the page that has been my 'home'page for as long as i can remember.

    Liked the old logo at the top better...the tabs being rounded seems a little odd. This is definitely design over usability.

    I thought this site catered quite well to the 'engineering type'...now the look certainly doesn't.

    I must mentione it again...the ads have *got* to be toned down...it's just way too much, 8 on one page.

    I hate to be so critical, but i don't even need a week to make my decision...the last time it changed, i could tell i /would/ like it. I'm not getting the same feeling here.
  • Guspaz - Tuesday, July 6, 2004 - link

    Another comment to add to my large list in comment #35:

    8) Where are the dates on the front page? There are no dates on the latest reviews, and no dates on the older reviews. On the old layout, every single review/article used to have a date. At the very least the latest articles need dates.
  • ee - Tuesday, July 6, 2004 - link

    The new interface would cost AT many readers in my opinion.

    As many people noted, a more detailed News section is sorely missed on the front page.

    Personally, I think I'll settle for the RSS feed, but that doesn't link to AT reviews.

    If I have to choose between easy-to-read news (RSS) and reviews (anandtech.com), convenience will win and I won't visit the AT site as much.

    Please reconsider adding the news, even as a non-default option.
  • steve - Tuesday, July 6, 2004 - link

    this isn't going to be very constructive - cbf'd, sorry. Suffice to say that I no longer to go your site on a daily basis as a result of your changes - I just don't see the information I require poppping out at me.

    Now I use your RSS feed, so I still get the latest information :)
  • steve - Tuesday, July 6, 2004 - link

    this isn't going to be very constructive - cbf'd, sorry. Suffice to say that I no longer to go your site on a daily basis as a result of your changes - I just don't see the information I require poppping out at me.

    No I use your RSS feed, so I still get the latest information :)
  • raskayu - Tuesday, July 6, 2004 - link

    Hey, it's much worse than the old design. You know, if something is working, just don't touch it!

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now