Performance Midrange Common Components

While AMD and Intel architectures differ in sockets and sometimes memory configurations, more is the same than not with the two systems. For that reason the Intel and AMD value midrange systems share a number of common components.

If you refer to the recent launch article on the ATI 4890 and NVIDIA GTX 275, you will find these two cards were initially the new choices for the $250 price point. Since then the very popular ATI 4890 has seen tremendous price competition among those selling the card. As a result, an overclocked 4890 can be had for $170 today after $30 rebate. While the GTX 275 performs similarly, it remains around the $250 selling price, with an occasional rebate pushing the price near $200. That is the reason the MSI 4890 OC is the video card choice for both performance midrange systems.

If you prefer NVIDIA cards or NVIDIA drivers, the GTX 275 is an easy substitute in either system. Either card will do the job well and you can shop based on price. The edge goes to the ATI 4890 in the resolutions you will likely run (1920x1200 or lower) with a 27" or smaller display. If you have a 30" monitor, the GTX 275 performs a bit better at those super high resolutions.

The case receives a significant upgrade with the selection of the unique Cooler Master Storm Scout mid-tower case. The Scout has many endearing features, but we would point out the unique rear cutout behind the CPU on the motherboard tray. That makes it possible to install many "through-the-board" aftermarket CPU heatsinks without removing the motherboard. It's a truly clever and useful design element, and we'd like to see more cases support such a feature. The top-mount handle and quiet, effective cooling are also big pluses. Some also want a unique appearance and the Storm Scout delivers with its red LED glow in a distinctive looking case.

Alternates are the Antec Nine Hundred at about the same price and the Antec 902 or Cooler Master Storm Sniper at $160. Both alternatives are very popular with system builders and buyers praise the build quality of both cases.

AnandTech and many other review sites have praised the solid construction, performance, and value of Corsair power supplies. It should come as no surprise that the Corsair 750TX is the choice to power either performance midrange system. The power supply is SLI Ready and CrossFire Ready, 80 PLUS Certified, and Core i7 ready. Power is delivered to a single 60A 12V rail for those looking for that feature and finding it hard to come by at a reasonable price. With a $20 rebate the final cost is $100, which is a great value for a PSU with these specifications, features, and performance reputation.

Most of our editors consider the onboard audio of motherboards to be more than adequate for even gaming these days. That is why we have not chosen a sound card for the performance midrange system. If you want more than onboard surround sound then we recommend the Auzentech X-Fi Forte 7.1 for serious gaming at $140. HTPC users will find much to like in the ASUS Xonar HDAV 1.3 Slim. Other good choices are the ASUS Xonar Essence STX for music, in particular for serious headphone users, or the HT Omega Claro Halo - both run about $200. If you are looking for a good general purpose onboard audio upgrade the HT Omega Striker 7.1 should fit your needs at around $90.

The optical drive for a performance midrange system needs the ability to play Blu-Ray disks. A new model was chosen here with the faster 8X BD read speeds, the LG CH08LS10 Blu-Ray/DVD combo drive. In addition to 8X BD and BD dual-layer playback, you can burn DVDs as fast as 16X single-layer or 12X DL. It cannot, however, burn 25GB/50GB Blu-Ray disks. Adding that capability increases the cost to around $200 to $250. BD burners like the $200 LITE-ON 4X BD-R SATA burner or the $230 LG GGW-H20LK 6X Blu-ray burner are good choices.

Speakers have been upgraded to the Logitech G51 155W RMS 5.1 surround sound speakers. The Logitech rebate has ended, but you can still find the G51 for as little as $120 if you shop, which makes the G51 an excellent value.

The LCD display resolution maintains the 1920 horizontal pixels of 1080p displays but moves to a 26" WUXGA display with a 1200 pixel height. Whatever the minor resolution differences the size of the monitor is increased to a nominal 26" so everything on screen is a little larger (0.292mm pixel pitch). The ASUS VW266H 25.5" HDMI widescreen provides the preferred HDMI input, as well as DVI and an analog VGA port. Panel speed is rated at an incredible 2ms, but we have found most current LCD panels perform similarly and the speed rating does not really guarantee very much. The ASUS monitor provides a large sharp image, good colors, and fast panel speed at a very good price of $300 after rebate. It comes with DVI and VGA cables, but if you plan to connect with HDMI you will need to buy an HDMI cable.

As most readers are aware, LCD panels have been going to cheaper panel technologies and generally declining in image quality. Despite that fact, most buyers are reporting that they are pleased with current LCD screens. It you have a need for exceptional color or yours is a mission-critical graphics task, you may want to look at the HP LP2475w 24" 1920x1200 monitor. This HP monitor is likely the best quality 24" monitor you can buy today, with superior panel technology (S-IPS) and image quality likely to satisfy graphics professionals.

The remaining components are the same as our value systems. The hard drive remains a 1TB WD. The Microsoft OEM keyboard and optical mouse provide input and Vista Home Premium OEM runs the system. For more information on these components you can refer to descriptions on p.3.

In response to those who have asked for SSD recommendations, it is possible to do so based on the months of research and testing performed on SSD drives at AnandTech. For more information on SSD test results please see our SSD Anthology and our SSD update. As we recently reported, you should be on the lookout for further price reductions expected in the next few weeks. The short summary is that the new Intel X25-M G2 SSDs are the top performers, but the price-reduced Indilinx options like the OCZ Vertex and OCZ Agility are viable competitors.

AMD Performance Midrange Intel Performance Midrange
Comments Locked

71 Comments

View All Comments

  • JonnyDough - Monday, July 27, 2009 - link

    I had no idea AMD had 45nm parts. Partly because I'm broke, partly because I've been really busy with life and work and was taking an interest in worthless women instead of keeping up on important stuff like tech I can't afford - and that was partly because I was getting tired of computer component naming schemes. I wonder when we'll be getting the Athlon XP II X3. I just hope it says "Super Mach Turbo Shizam!" on the decal that comes with it so I know it's really fast.
  • JarredWalton - Monday, July 27, 2009 - link

    Just FYI, as is often the case several items listed in the original guide have gone out of stock at one vendor, so I have changed the links to another vendor with a similar price. You may find minor differences (less than $10) and no updates have been made to the text, but the original math at least works out. :-)

    --Jarred Walton
  • Regs - Monday, July 27, 2009 - link

    Under Intel Value system your have the case linked to a blue-ray rom.
  • JarredWalton - Monday, July 27, 2009 - link

    Fixed, thanks.
  • jonup - Monday, July 27, 2009 - link

    Jarred, Microcenter carries CPUs at very discounted prices (unlike most other stuff). They had the Q9550 for $169+tax which is close to the price of your e8400. And their i920 is $199 + tax. I am not questioning the choice of processor, just suggestion to squeez an extra buck out of the build.
  • bigboxes - Saturday, August 1, 2009 - link

    Just wanted to say thanks for the heads up. My mobo, which is almost 3 years old, wouldn't post after I returned home after a week away on business. So, being the tech guy I am decided to finally build a new machine. After five AMD boxes I have finally returned to the dark side. There's just no equivalent in the performance range. I got the i7 920 for $216 ($199 + tax) from the Microcenter here in North Dallas. I will be getting the rest of the parts in the next couple of weeks. The cpu was $280 at newegg and @$200 I just couldn't pass up the deal.
  • Nfarce - Monday, July 27, 2009 - link

    "They had the Q9550 for $169+tax which is close to the price of your e8400. And their i920 is $199 + tax."

    They still do actually.

    http://www.microcenter.com/single_product_results....">http://www.microcenter.com/single_product_results....

    http://www.microcenter.com/single_product_results....">http://www.microcenter.com/single_product_results....

    These prices are good for the entire month of July, so if you were ever debating on getting one of these, now is the time.
  • JarredWalton - Monday, July 27, 2009 - link

    Problem is, they're in-store-only offers, which means you need a Microcenter in the area. There are plenty of readers that don't have that option, but if you do Microcenter's deals on CPUs are always worth a look.
  • The0ne - Monday, July 27, 2009 - link

    They are always in-store. Most people can't get them because MicroCenter B&M is very few and far between. Heck there's only one I know of here in Southern CA and it's about a 2 hour drive to get there! :)
  • jonup - Tuesday, July 28, 2009 - link

    I can say the same for Fry's. We do not have any in Michigan and shipping usually spoils the deal.

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now