Video Memory Bus - Hasta la vista, buses...

One of the most unaddressed topics for mobility products has been memory bus termination. Buses are routed on high speed PCB traces that work in the similar sense to transmission lines. If you leave the "lines" open, electrical signals could reflect back and distortion with the communication of the controller and controlled devices. Signal distortion can produce or contribute to things like erroneous bits in data, false memory addresses, etc. The way to avoid this is to use termination to close each end of the buses with resistor circuits.

As far as we know, there are no mobile GPU designs that use full termination (also called parallel termination). Serial and no termination have been the traditional methods used for virtually all notebook designs. Note that ATI's own brand of desktop cards implement full termination. This is in the sense of the GPU memory bus not the AGP bus, which are independent of one another.

This is what Rahul Sood, President of Voodoo PC, had to say on the topic:
There are traditionally three memory termination options depending on trade-offs amongst performance, power consumption and PCB space. They are: no termination (lowest speed, least PCB space requirement), serial, and full termination (highest speed, largest PCB space requirement).

For short traces (< 2 inches), the so called "half parallel" termination, essentially full termination without the series resistor, is a good compromise between performance and space requirement.
The implementation of full termination comes with several trade offs, like increased power consumption/thermal emissions and an increase in necessary PCB real estate, while the system generally benefits from performance and the ability to crack up the clocks. We have been told that there may be a fully terminated Mobility Radeon 9700 design popping up sometime soon, but the details are still sketchy at this point.
NVIDIA GeForce FX Go5700 – And so the tumbleweed rolled... The Test
Comments Locked

14 Comments

View All Comments

  • alexruiz - Tuesday, February 3, 2004 - link

    Andrew, did you run 3Dmark 2001SE? Do you have the score as reference?

    My guess: Checking the list, you can see that almost ALL the ODMs are included. The manufacturers who make machines for the biggest OEMs are included. 2 missing ones that I noticed are Mitac and Arima, and my guess of the unannounced ODM is ARIMA.... thus, the big OEM announcement will be..... you got the picture :)

    W740K8-D? :P
  • Serp86 - Tuesday, February 3, 2004 - link

    Or maybe begins with s, ends with y, and has 4 letters.

    Anyway, the 9700 looks pretty darn good
  • Durt - Tuesday, February 3, 2004 - link

    What is the price difference between the two (9600 pro and 9700).
  • PrinceGaz - Tuesday, February 3, 2004 - link

    I wonder who the other BIG unannounced notebook manufacturer using it is... from a wild guess I'd bet the name begins with 'D' and has four letters :p

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now