IDE RAID Comparison

by Matthew Witheiler on June 18, 2001 4:31 AM EST

Promise SuperTRAK100

The second IDE hardware RAID controller that we took a look at was the Promise SuperTRAK100. A full length PCI card, the SuperTRAK100 is the same size as the AAA-UDMA but has a few more features.

First off, Promise is a company that has been in the IDE business for some time. As a result of this, the card is a true IDE hardware RAID controller, not a SCSI card modified to read and write to IDE devices. The SuperTRAK100 is much simpler as far as design.

The coprocessor of the SuperTRAK100 is an Intel i960RD which is actually an I/O processor. The chip operates at 66MHz and has a built in PCI-to-PCI bridge, memory controller, and support for the I2O specification. I2O is an architecture that provides support for intelligent I/O and is the standard supported in almost every operating system today and provides the maximum offload of RAID functions from the CPU onto the chip. It is the i960RD that performs the XOR calculations necessary for parity bits as well as other RAID specific functions.

The i960RD chip sends its information to up to six hard drives powered by three Promise PDC20265 chips located on the board. Like the Adaptec solution, each IDE port on the SuperTRAK100 only accepts one master drive to prevent any unnecessary slow down. The PDC20265 also provides support for the ATA100 specification.

For cache memory, the SuperTRAK100 uses a single 72-pin EDO SIMM. Our card came installed with a 16MB stick, but amounts up to 128MB are supported.

The card features a set of 4 LEDs located on the back panel of the card. These lights allow for easy trouble shooting of the RAID array, as the system does not have to be dismantled to find out what is going wrong. During normal operation, the LEDs move in a back and forth fashion to indicate that all is well. Also included for diagnostic purposes is a speaker as well as a connection for an audio source other than the built-in speaker.

Other than that, there is not much else to the SuperTRAK100 hardware wise. There is the standard pin-header for hard drive LED activity lights, a battery to power the BIOS, and a Lattice BIOS chip.

ADAPTEC AAA-UDMA About the Test
Comments Locked

2 Comments

View All Comments

  • kburrows - Thursday, December 4, 2003 - link

    Have you run any tests on any onboard RAID solutions for RAID 0 & 1? I would love to see the results posted for the new SATA RAID on the Intel 875 boards.
  • Anonymous User - Sunday, August 17, 2003 - link

    In adressing the performance of an raid array with different stripe sizes, you miss an important factor, namely the accestime of an disk. This wait time has two main couses. First the head positioning and second the rotational latency (the heads track the right trace, but position where the read start has not passed under the head). You may have to wait from 0 to (in the worst case) a full cycle.
    Since the disks move independently You can calculate that the average latency to get an small file is minimal when the stripe size is about an full cycle of an disk in the array (aprox. 250kB today). All other factors I do know do not reduce this. (controller overhead, transport,...)
    So I think that today a minimum stripe size of 256kB should be used.

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now