The Xeon E5-2600: Dual Sandy Bridge for Servers
by Johan De Gelas on March 6, 2012 9:27 AM EST- Posted in
- IT Computing
- Virtualization
- Xeon
- Opteron
- Cloud Computing
LS-DYNA
LS-DYNA is a "general purpose structural and fluid analysis simulation software package capable of simulating complex real world problems", developed by the Livermore Software Technology Corporation (LSTC). It is used by the automobile, aerospace, construction, military, manufacturing and bioengineering industry. Even simple simulations take hours to complete, so even a small performance increase results in tangible savings. Add to that that many of our readers have been asking that we perform some benchmarking with HPC workloads. So reasons enough to include our own LS-DYNA benchmarking.
These numbers are not directly comparable with AMD's and Intel's benchmarks as we did not perform any special tuning besides using the message passing interface (MPI) version of LS-DYNA ( ls971_mpp_hpmpi ) to run the LS-DYNA solver to get maximum scalability. This is HP-MPI version of LS-DYNA 9.71.
Our first test is a refined revised Neon crash test simulation.
This is one of the few benchmarks (besides SAP) where the Opteron 6276 outperforms the older Opteron 6174 by a tangible margin (about 20% faster) and is significantly faster than the Xeon 5600, by 40% to be more precise. However, the direct competitor of the 6276, the Xeon E5-2630, will do a bit better (see the E5-2660 6C score). When you are aiming for the best performance, it is impossible to beat the best Xeons: the Xeon E5-2660 offers 26% better performance, the 2690 is 46% faster. It is interesting to note that LS-Dyna does not scale well with clockspeed: the 32% higher clockspeed of the Xeon E5-2690 results in only a 15% speed increase.
A few other interesting things to note: we saw only a very smal performance increase (+5%) due to Hyperthreading. Memory bandwidth does not seem to be critical either, as performance increased by only 6% when we replaced DDR3-1333 with DDR3-1600. If LS-Dyna was bottlenecked severely by the memory speed we should have seen a performance increase close to 20% (1600 vs 1333).
CMT boosted the Opteron 6276's performance by up to 33%, which seems weird at first since LS-DYNA is a typical floating point intensive application. As the shared floating point "outsources" load and stores to the integer cores, the most logical explanation is that LS-DYNA is limited by the load/store bandwidth. This is in sharp contrast with for example 3DS Max where the additional overhead of 16 extra threads slowed the shared FP down instead of speeding it up.
Also, both CPUs seem to have made good use of their turbo capabilities. The AMD Opteron was running at 2.6 GHz most of the time, the Xeon 2690 at 3.3 GHz and the Xeon 2660 at 2.6 GHz.
The second test is the "Three Vehicle Collision Test" simulation, which runs a lot longer.
The three vehicle collision test does not change the benchmarking picture, it confirms our early findings. The Opteron Interlagos does well, but the Xeon E5 is the new HPC champion.
Facebook
Twitter
RSS
81 Comments
View All Comments
dilidolo - Tuesday, March 6, 2012 - link
Link not working on first page - THE SPECS AND THE SKUSyvizel - Tuesday, March 6, 2012 - link
For some reason I cannot go beyond the first page...yvizel - Tuesday, March 6, 2012 - link
Second page, in the Intel table, the 2630 is listed as an eight core CPU.But then: "...Based on the paper specs, AMD's 6276, 6274 and Intel's 2640 and 2630 are in a neck-and-neck race. AMD offers 16 smaller integer clusters, while Intel offers 6 heavy, slightly higher clocked cores with SMT..."
JohanAnandtech - Tuesday, March 6, 2012 - link
Fixed, thanks for letting me know!-Johan
Assimilator87 - Tuesday, March 6, 2012 - link
Ah man, the 2630L error totally got my hopes up. 8 cores for $662 would be very reasonable.jumjjcmsw - Thursday, November 10, 2016 - link
How do celebrities keep fit and be always on top? Simple, complete with exercise and of course the right diet. In Hollywood it every day a new diet is devised that promises weight loss in a short time and a fabulous body. From the fasting diet to that of the Paleolithic, up to that of the blood type, the stars follow them a bit 'all.http://www.celebritiesphonenumber.com/baby-ariel-p...
Kjella - Tuesday, March 6, 2012 - link
...just got bulldozed. And this isn't even on the 22nm 3D transistors they're launching next month, it's like they just got a dizzying punch and know the KO punch is coming.A5 - Tuesday, March 6, 2012 - link
It'll probably be awhile before the Ivy Bridge Xeons are out.Kjella - Tuesday, March 6, 2012 - link
Of course, I'm guessing Q1 2013 before we'll see those but we already know from all the leaked SB -> IB details roughly what SB-Xeon to IB-Xeon will be like. All AMD has on their roadmap for 2013 is the "Abu Dhabi" with the "Piledriver" core promising 10-15% performance boost but still on 32nm. So you can see the punch coming a year away, but I don't think AMD has the capability to do anything about it.saharadusud - Saturday, January 7, 2017 - link
http://clashroyalehacke.com/Do you want unlimited gems, gold and elixirs without spending money? You can enjoy free gems by using the Clash Royale Hack with the latest version, easy to use with proxy support. With such a feature, you can truly enjoy yourself in the game and complete things you want without much trouble. This will make your time spent playing either less hard work and more fun. This is why we recommend our tool for all enthusiasts of the video game.
The good news is that this tool works well with any Android phone, iPad, PC and iPhone. What's even better is the fact that this tool is free to use for any player who wants to take full advantage of its features. This is the Clash Royale Hack tool that can be used to generate Clash Royale gems easily and for free. This works in a secure manner, which will allow you to remain reassured in the integrity of your account if you use our tool. Sit down and relax as you continue to generate free gems for you.