The Montac ArcticCircle
 
In the x86 PC world, CPUs with extremely high power usage (40W and more) are quite new -- previous x86 CPU generations used much less power. But the manufacturers of UNIX workstations had been confronted with the problem of very high heat emission long before, and thus have started developing their own cooling solutions. For example, HP is selling computers with CPUs that gobble up over 100W. It's obvious that they had to develop very efficient CPU coolers in order to cope with that heat. But HP's proprietary cooling technology was not available to PC users - until recently, when a surplus stock of a heatsink model that they're no longer using for their workstations was dumped on the market. A few heatsink vendors have started selling these heatsinks under various names ("Panaflo ORB", "HP Turbocooler", "HP/Polarlogic heatsink"), and two retailers are even selling these HP heatsinks with mounting mechanisms suitable for PC CPUs. The Montac Cable store is selling the HP heatsinks with a proprietary mounting mechanism, suitable for Athlon CPUs. They call this cooler the "ArcticCircle" - look at the picture to find out why:
 

As you can see, this unit looks a lot different from other heatsinks. The cooler is produced using CNC milling, which is a very expensive production method - but since these heatsinks are surplus, they're available at affordable prices, and even the ArcticCircle with Athlon clips is not extremely expensive.

HP's innovative heatsink design is certainly good.- Considering the compactness and the fact that it is only equipped with one fan, the performance is remarkable. Even though it does not cool as well as the Global WIN VOS32 and the Alpha P7125, it is still suitable for overclocking. One thing that helps the ArcticCircle to perform well is the fact that it is mounted directly on the Athlon CPU core, without the Athlon's thermal transfer plate. This is both an advantage and a disadvantage - the advantage is that there is less thermal resistance between CPU and heatsink; the disadvantage is that you'll have to open your Athlon (thus voiding its warranty) and remove the thermal plate. But since overclockers will have to open their Athlon anyway in order to install the "gold finger overclocking device", this disadvantage shouldn't really matter. Unfortunately, the ArcticCircle is not compatible with all Athlon overclocking devices - it won't work with the Outer Loop Afterburner card because of a mechanical problem. However, other overclocking devices will work.

If the Athlon thermal transfer plate is removed, the Athlon's cache chips aren't cooled anymore. To solve this problem, Montac includes tiny heatsinks for the cache chips with the ArcticCircle. Three of these mini-heatsinks (see picture) should be installed on each cache chip. Despite their small size, they definitely provide sufficient cooling for the cache chips - compared to the CPU, the cache does not emit much heat, and the ArcticCircle blows quite a lot of air towards the cache, so with the small heatsinks, the cache chips stay comfortably cool.

As interface material for the "main" heatsink, Montac includes a tiny ziplock bag with a drop of thermal compound.

 

The fan

 
The ArcticCircle comes with an embedded "Panaflo" fan, made by Panasonic. The fan is not extremely loud - the noise level is acceptable. The ArcticCircle's fan does not support rpm monitoring. The third wire coming from the fan is not an rpm signal wire, but a locked rotor signal wire, and PC motherboards don't support this method of fan monitoring. Also, the ArcticCircle isn't connected to the motherboard, it gets its power from a pass-through power supply connector.

 

Installation
 

The heatsink is attached to the CPU using four screws. The plastic case of the Athlon can be either left on or removed. If it is left on, you will have to cut out a part of it, and drill four holes into the case. Montac includes everything you'll need for installation: A printed manual with pictures, all screws, plastic spacers, and even alcohol swabs to clean the CPU core and the cache chips before installing the heatsinks. Installation is a bit time-consuming, but with some patience, the ArcticCircle can be installed easily, thanks to the installation manual. The weak point is the cache heatsink installation: They are fixed using thermoconductive tape, and it's quite difficult to get the protection film off the tape. Also, it remains to be seen whether the tape will hold the small heatsinks reliably over the years. The cache heatsinks could be removed very easily after the test. The mounting mechanism for the actual "CPU heatsink" is very good, it allows compressive mounting, which is good for thermal transfer between CPU and heatsink.

 

Conclusion

 
While not the top performer in this comparison, this heatsink was nevertheless very convincing: "Smart" design that combines compactness and efficiency, good mounting mechanism, and it can be mounted directly on the CPU core. However, the HP heatsinks on which the ArcticCircle is based are no longer in production, so it looks like this cooler will only be available for a limited time.

 
 
Montac ArcticCircle at a glance
Fan: One 60mm Panaflo
Fan rpm (measured): unknown


Weight: 400g

Advantages
  • Compact design - fits all motherboards, does not block any DIMM slots
  • Good performance, considering the size and the fact that it uses only one fan
  • Not very loud
  • Can be mounted directly on the Athlon CPU core
Disadvantages
  • Installation requires opening the Athlon
  • No rpm monitoring
  • Not compatible with OuterLoop Afterburner overclocking card
Alpha P7125CM60 w/ Sanyo Denki fans RDJD K701
Comments Locked

0 Comments

View All Comments

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now