Battery Life and Charging

Battery life is one of those things that consistently ranks among the highest in consideration for a mobile device. At the same time, OEMs still seem largely unwilling to double or triple battery capacities between generations, or go the Motorola route and offer two different models with double capacity. The story of smartphones is again this continual competition between everything and the industrial design.

With the One, HTC has gone again to its pyramidal stack of display, then battery, then PCB. The result is the familiar curved backside from where the PCB sits, and a large, thin battery sandwiched between the display and PCB.

The HTC One moves to a 2300 mAh, 3.8V (the higher nominal chemistry that everyone has moved to) lithium-ion polymer battery, giving it a capacity of 8.74 watt-hours. It’s obviously internal and not easily user-replaceable. Of course, battery size doesn’t entirely dictate battery life, it’s just a larger electron tank to draw from. What ultimately is a more interesting is how efficient the platform is which draws from it.

The thing about HTC and battery life specifically is that as of late they’ve been penalizing themselves on the display side of things, which is the single largest consumer of power in a device. A number of other OEMs artificially clamp display brightness just to set a better higher bound for battery life, and for example HTC’s display auto brightness function doesn’t have as much dynamic range as the slider being actuated manually. The result is a phone that’s brighter than it needs to be a lot of the time. On the software side HTC does have system optimizations that do things like batch up network traffic so that the phone isn’t going into a constant cellular connected state and burning power for an app written by a developer who doesn’t know anything about cellular connection state tables, and strategies like suspending the cellular data connection when on WiFi or when the phone is in standby for long periods.

To find out where the HTC One sits in the battery life spectrum, we turn to the newest version of our battery life test. This is now our sixth revision of the battery life test, and we feel is the optimal balance between challenging workloads and idle time. The basic overview is the same as the previous test — we load webpages at a fixed interval until the handset dies, with display set at exactly 200 nits as always. Power saving features (in this case the HTC Power Saver) are disabled if they turn on automatically, and background account sync is disabled. The test is performed over both cellular data on all available air interfaces and over WiFi in an environment with good signal levels. The new test has decreased pause time between web page loads and added a number of JavaScript-heavy pages. I sat down with some UMTS RRC (Radio Resource Control) emulator tools and also made sure we had a good balance of all the RRC states (DCH, PCH if possible, FACH, IDLE) so we weren’t heavily biased towards one mode or the other.

I’ve included the HTC DNA in the fray as well since I’ve had those numbers for a while. Let’s start with the WiFi test, where we attach the device to a dedicated WiFi network with no other clients.

AT Smartphone Bench 2013: Web Browsing Battery Life (WiFi)

The One includes the newest BCM4335 WiFi/BT/FM combo from Broadcom, which is still built on a 40nm process. For the purpose of the battery life test I attached the One to the same AP as I’ve always used, however I will repeat with my 802.11ac AP in due time to see whether the shorter duty cycle afforded by a much higher PHY rate makes any difference.

AT Smartphone Bench 2013: Web Browsing Battery Life (3G/4G LTE)

On cellular data the One isn’t bad at all, looking at the 3G result from final hardware and final software. I consider this pretty good all things considered for the HTC One, and mirrors my experience.

Cellular Talk Time

On cellular talk time the One really shines, coming in well ahead of almost everything else. This is an impressive result.

WiFi Hotspot Battery Life Time

As a hotspot once again we have great battery performance. This test consists of four of the page loading tabs running on an attached notebook in addition to 128kbps streaming MP3 audio being played on the device. This is a challenging test that results in the cellular connection being lit up almost constantly, and isolates out display.

My subjective impressions using the HTC One as my personal device are that battery life is quite good, and moreover that the DNA battery life also was better than some other phones people had no problems with in 2012. I have yet to have an issue making it through an entire day on the HTC One, even when aggressively using the camera. If I knew I was going to be away from the charger for a long time, I did enable the power saver, which sets max CPU clock on the Snapdragon 600 to around 1.3 GHz in addition to lowering brightness a little bit, and a few other things as shown in the previous screenshot. In practice I really don’t notice much of a performance difference with the power saver box checked unless I’m really looking for it, but this probably dumps the SoC into a better voltage state to say nothing of how much lower active power is.

Charging on the HTC One takes a little while longer than I’m used to for other devices. I get lots of requests to do charging tests and have been running them on everything I can lately, but anything power related remains an involved process. To test the best case charge time, I have a dedicated power supply voltage limited to 5V and capable of supplying a lot of current. I emulate the USB BC1.2 charging spec on a breadboard and connect USB to the device, then time how long it takes to charge devices completely. I plug the phone in after it dies running our battery life test, and time the amount of time from that fully dead, won’t-turn-on state to fully charged, either with a green LED or when charge current goes to zero for devices without a charge status LED.

Device Charge Time - 0 to 100 Percent

The HTC One definitely takes a while to charge. What’s interesting however is that the charge curve gets the One to 85–90 percent under the normal 3 or so hours, it’s that last ten percent that takes forever. I also have confirmed that Qualcomm’s Quick Charge is not being used on the HTC One, for whatever reason, possibly to maximize compatibility with the portable USB battery chargers that are now proliferating. The PMIC is there, it just isn’t enabled. My guess would be that HTC wants to prioritize battery longevity and minimize any even potential extra wear since the battery on the One is sealed inside.

Hardware (Continued) and Cases HTC's Ultrapixels - Bucking The Trend


View All Comments

  • mschira - Thursday, April 11, 2013 - link

    Well that tough to change battery is a bit of a worry. And the iFixit guide is not very reassuring.
    So one would hope HTC will offer battery replacement services?
    Do they comment on this?
  • superflex - Friday, April 12, 2013 - link

    When you battery wont hold a charge to your satisfaction, drop the phone in the toilet and make a claim on your insurance. That's how the iPhone crowd rolls. Reply
  • nerdstalker - Sunday, April 14, 2013 - link

    What insurance? Does HTC confirm to have it 100%? Reply
  • Sir_Funk - Friday, April 12, 2013 - link

    IJudge, it seems nothing like a sponsored review please give anandtech some integrity.

    Anyone who is worried about the sealed battery they usually just replace the phone rather than the battery. Also anyone who is that worried about not having a replaceable battery just take out a small battery charger which isn't much bigger than a replacement battery. Great review and a great phone.
  • mebalzer - Saturday, April 13, 2013 - link

    Good point, I have a Galaxy Nexus and never replace the battery. It is always easier to hook up a charger, or external battery pack than to pull of the case, then back of the phone, which could lead to dropping it or worse. Reply
  • Thud2 - Friday, April 12, 2013 - link

    Can anyone say if this phone has a clearcoat type finish? I would guess it does but I am going to take some PPG Eldorado aircraft paint remover, tape of the area around that "Beats" logo and remove that shit. It will not damage Aluminum (or Aluminium). I really do not want to carry around an $800 sandwich board for Dr Dre. Reply
  • CNP-Keythai - Saturday, April 13, 2013 - link

    Fantastic exterior accessories. As good as ours, I bet. Reply
  • mebalzer - Saturday, April 13, 2013 - link

    I have a lot of respect for the writers on this site as well as their podcasts. These are real technical writers who go the extra mile to provide a complete analysis. This review will go a long way on determining my next phone. I hope they provide a comprehensive report on the Samsung S4 as well. Sadly, am I correct to believe this will not be offered by Verizon? Reply
  • Commodus - Sunday, April 14, 2013 - link

    Verizon has so far said that it's not planning to carry the One, but there's been conflicting talk on that front. One theory is that it's repeating a 2012 strategy of demanding a custom device, or else waiting for another device timed for later in the year (a la Droid DNA). Reply
  • superflex - Wednesday, April 17, 2013 - link

    Verizon will get the HTC One Droid Razer Maxx HD in sucker blood red with a SD slot and a extended replaceable battery.
    Of course, the screen size will have to be reduced to allow for their carrier branding.

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now