Anand's Thoughts on Google's Chrome OS
by Anand Lal Shimpi on December 8, 2010 6:23 PM ESTPerformance
Atom is fast enough to run a Chrome browser and without the burden of Windows 7 I’d expect Chrome notebooks to be fast enough for most things. It remains to be seen how smooth things like scrolling Flash video playback will be however.
Google did provide two measures of performance in its announcement yesterday. Chrome OS should boot in around 10 seconds and wake from sleep instantly. These two imply that there’s some element of solid state storage at play within the Cr-48 but I’m still awaiting confirmation from Google. Edit: Storage on the Cr-48 is confirmed to be all solid state, no platters, thanks everyone!
ISA Independence
Chrome OS is currently only supported by Intel x86 platforms and will launch with Atom based designs, however with the apps running on Chrome OS being web based, from a developer standpoint the Chrome OS is effectively ISA independent.
If Google (or someone else, the OS being open source) chooses to port Chrome OS to ARM, so long as the underlying OS is full featured, apps that run on an x86 version would run on an ARM version. This leaves a huge opportunity for ARM to enter the notebook/netbook market with the Cortex A15 in the coming years. The OEMs would have to demand it however, and I suspect we will only see that if Intel drops the ball on being price/performance competitive in this space.
Whereas an ARM (or non-x86) threat to Intel never really existed in the Windows world, it’s very possible with Chrome OS.
I will add that while Chrome OS could enable ARM based notebooks, I don’t suspect that will happen in a major way anytime soon given what I know of Intel and ARM’s respective processor roadmaps.
Facebook
Twitter
RSS
104 Comments
View All Comments
Roland00Address - Wednesday, December 8, 2010 - link
Netbooks are routinely $300 or less now. $300 for a 6 cell, 160 gb hard drive for the everyday price of a Netbook in a retail store. If you wait for a sale the price is usually $249 to $279, and on a mega sale like black friday you can get a netbook for $199 (though usually a 3 cell battery). You can get a dual core atom n550 netbook for $329 to $349 (not on sale, the normal everday price at a retail location.).The cost of a Windows 7 Starter license is between $45 and $55
http://arstechnica.com/microsoft/news/2009/06/micr...
http://www.sunrainet.com/windows-7-starter-edition...
Google is expect there chrome netbooks to be $300 to $400. Sure part of this cost is the obscene cost of a Gobi modem (which you can get for about $100 retail) but this obscene price for a Gobi modem eats away the microsoft tax and more.
------
I am just trying to see the value of Chrome as it currently is implemented. I understand it will be virus free and feel faster than a typical netbook. The problem is you will be hard pressed to sell this to the normal individual. Furthermore with the upcoming AMD Brazo (Low Power fusion) coming out in q1 2011 and retailing in the $300 to $500 range netbooks are going to feel less slow then they do now. Thus the only real advantages is it boots faster and is virus free; what you lose is all the productivity that current windows offers.
Right now Google is offering an all or nothing for $300 to $400 bucks you can have a windows netbook something you already know and understand or you can have a google chrome netbook, something that is new and at first glance to a "normal individual" looks more limited.
Personally I think Chrome would make more sense as an add-on to existing netbooks. If google dropped the Gobi modem requirement, then all OEMs would have to do is add a few gbs of flash memory via a mini pci express slot. You can have your windows as well as your linux operating system that boots very quickly, feels faster, and has all these free google apps. Google will still get their fabalous data mining and advertising engine and they will get it into more people's hands and thus more eyeballs.
gr00 - Friday, January 14, 2011 - link
I agree on the pricing calculation. In my book for such a device hardware-wise and software-wise should feel like a natural evolution of netbook. Therefore should cost the same since they offer same or trade-off features.Most mobile phones could do these things if there was need.
The biggest strength of Chrome OS is the unification of tendencies during the last year or two: netbooks + web apps + cloud + ssd + new OS.
It imho bases a new idea of casual un-personal trustfull computing which will soon become a rival to todays PC computing.
kmmatney - Wednesday, December 8, 2010 - link
I personally removed the Caps lock key from my work keyboard - it did more harm than good.tipoo - Wednesday, December 8, 2010 - link
IT WILL HELP THE INTERNET FOR OBVIOUS REASONSExodite - Wednesday, December 8, 2010 - link
Win of the day.racerx_is_alive - Wednesday, December 8, 2010 - link
Removing the Caps Lock key is one thing, replacing it with a search button is something else entirely.Instead of having to go back and erase a few all caps letters, you get a brief lag while it brings up a search box? A browser window? Something that steals the focus either way, and keeps you letters from going where they are supposed to be.
I'm not sure that's progress.
kmmatney - Wednesday, December 8, 2010 - link
I need it on my home machine for games, though.mino - Wednesday, December 8, 2010 - link
$20 for 1GB ? Reasonable ? Are hope you are not serious.wait, there is more:
$50 for 5GB ? WTF ? and ZERO unlimited plans ? Are you joking ?
OK, to be clear:
I had $20 2GB plan in 2004(!) with USB EDGE modem in plan
- mind you, it was in no way subsidized, they made big money on these)
Now, I have, $15 plan, with 5GB FUP and no overcharge, USB 3G modem in plan
- FUP == 64kbps after you go over it
I can also upgrade to 20GB plan (FUP, no oevrcharge) for $30, just for kicks of it.
All this in Slovakia, a VERY mountainous country, with 40% rural population (think <3000 villages), with 90% 3G/99% EDGE population coverage and ~$10k average yearly gross income.
Why am I saying it ? Because from long-term mobile user experience 2GB plan, while OOK in 2004, is a joke in the time of YouTube. Hell those 5 gigs are barely there (so the FUP really helps me here).
In the end they are selling a $400 "notebook" that is pretty much useless without $50 monthly "monopoly tax".
Sound a real bargain up from here ...
/sorry but I had to write this rant.
The idea of respected journalist believing $20/GB rates are reasonable in 2010 is just SO WRONG.
Anand Lal Shimpi - Wednesday, December 8, 2010 - link
I agree that data plans are way overpriced, my praise is really due to the free 100mb per month and no contract requirements. Those two make me happy, but yes I'd like to see an overhaul of the rest of the pricing structure.Take care,
Anand
mino - Thursday, December 9, 2010 - link
In my experience 100MB is about 1/2 a day of conservative browsing so it is more of a teaser that anything.Well is actually the single good thing that no-agreement part. Otherwise this looks a pure cash cow for Telcos.