550W Roundup: Three PSUs at Different Prices
by Martin Kaffei on October 28, 2010 4:00 PM ESTTechsolo Voltage Regulation and Quality
| +3.3V regulation | |
| Load | Voltage |
| 10% | 3.35V (+1.52%) |
| 20% | 3.32V (+0.61%) |
| 50% | 3.23V (-2,12%) |
| 80% | |
| 100% | |
| 110% | |
| +5V regulation | |
| Load | Voltage |
| 10% | 5.06V (+1.2%) |
| 20% | 4.99V (-0.2%) |
| 50% | 4.79V (-4.2%) |
| 80% | |
| 100% | |
| 110% | |
| +12V regulation | |
| Load | Voltage 12V1/V2 |
| 10% | 12.01V (+0.17%)/ 12.02V (+0.18%) |
| 20% | 11.99V (-0.08%)/ 12.02V (+0.18%) |
| 50% | 11.93V (-0.58%)/ 11.90V (-0.83%) |
| 80% | |
| 100% | |
| 110% | |
Uh oh! As you can see, the PSU died after 50% load—the two main switches exploded! All the rails are still within specification at 50%, but you can see large voltage drops and +5V is close to the limit of -5%. +12V stays stable with more than 11.90V at all tested loads, but naturally the failure at 80% load is a major black mark.
Ripple and Noise
| +3.3V ripple quality | |
| Load | Ripple and noise |
| 10% | 7.20mV |
| 20% | 7.70mV |
| 50% | 14.30mV |
| 80% | |
| 100% | |
| 110% | |
| +5V ripple quality | |
| Load | Ripple and noise |
| 10% | 7.90mV |
| 20% | 11.70mV |
| 50% | 21.40mV |
| 80% | |
| 100% | |
| 110% | |
| +12V ripple quality | |
| Load | Ripple and noise |
| 10% | 19.50mV |
| 20% | 32.90mV |
| 50% | 63.70mV |
| 80% | |
| 100% | |
| 110% | |
The ripple and noise results aren't that bad, but the ripple on +12V could be lower. 64mV is half of the spec, but we've seen worse results there. In fact, some $150 PSUs aren't better here, but deliver the full power and shut down if there is a problem. Again, the failure of the Techsolo at 80% is a key point; it may kill your hardware, so stay away from this product.
Facebook
Twitter
RSS
82 Comments
View All Comments
jimhsu - Thursday, October 28, 2010 - link
Silentpcreview also does high quality PSU reviews, though aimed at a slightly different market (hence the name). They do review performance PSUs though.Mathieu Bourgie - Thursday, October 28, 2010 - link
There's also the EggXpert (NewEgg forums) Tiered Power Supply List that's a good reference (http://www.eggxpert.com/forums/thread/323050.aspx)... as well as *cough* shameless plug *cough* my own article on the subject "Warning: 6 Surefire Ways of Blowing Up Your Computer Due to an Inadequate Power Supply" located here: http://www.hardware-revolution.com/warning-6-suref...Due for an update for the recommendations at the end, rest is still pretty much valid.
Phaedrus2129 - Friday, October 29, 2010 - link
The EggXpert list a terrible reference, out of date and full of mistakes.tomoyo - Friday, October 29, 2010 - link
There's an amazing amount of mediocre/crap psus that are in the Tier 2 section, and yet there's also some very good psus that are somehow Tier 4. I'd say a mostly useless list.hybrid2d4x4 - Friday, October 29, 2010 - link
+1 for SilentPCReview's PSU reviews, though I'd say it's not necessarily a niche for audiophiles/noise-reducing obsessive-compulsives as the name may suggest: they only have one page (of 5-7) for acoustics. The rest is a knowledgeable analysis with some of the most detailed electrical testing and thermal torture testing.erple2 - Wednesday, November 3, 2010 - link
The folks at pcper.com are also particularly good at doing proper PSU reviews. They're one of the only ones I know of that do an analysis of cross-loading - ie heavily load one rail and see how it affects the voltage at the other leads (3.3, 5, 12). They're also a group that I've come to rely on for solid PSU reviews. Now if only they'd do more testing ...Phaedrus2129 - Thursday, October 28, 2010 - link
There should have been some comment on the immediately obvious signs that the TechSolo was going to be mediocre. First thing pointed out should have been the "P4PFC" on the label. This indicates that A.) This PSU is actually an ATX12V 1.x era unit, since it's advertising "P4" or "Pentium 4 compatibility", and second having "PFC" after the P4 indicates that this is a platform that doesn't come with PFC as stock, indicating that it's a lower-end unit.Did the TechSolo fail on the primary or secondary side (before or after the transformer)? If it failed on the primary (perhaps the rectifying bridge went nuclear?) then it would be unlikely, though still possible, for it to kill components. If it was a secondary side component that failed then this PSU is a potential time bomb waiting to wipe out your PC.
mmatis - Thursday, October 28, 2010 - link
on September 12th from Newegg ($64.99 with free shipping and $20 MIR), the OCZ Fatal1ty OCZ550FTY doesn't seem like a bad buy to me. But then it's just running an AMD X4, a couple of hard drives, optical drive, and low end video card.slickr - Thursday, October 28, 2010 - link
Good job in this review, though I would like to see more PSU reviews and possibly include A-Power supplies.Beenthere - Thursday, October 28, 2010 - link
There are a lot of posers in the PSU market including some non PSU based companies adding questionable PSUs to the product mix. I'll continue to just buy PC Power and Cooling PSUs which are the gold standard of the PC industry. No guessing required with a PCPC PSU. They perform as advertised and are guaranteed for 5-7 yrs. depending on model.