Meet Manveer. I’ve known him since I was in the 6th grade. Somewhere around the 8th grade we started a ritual of calling each other every day after school and talking about video games, computers and dumb things that happened at school. We talked on the phone for hours. Back in those days we would even play the same game on separate computers while talking on the phone. It was a precursor to voice chat in gaming networks like Steam or Xbox Live. It was ridiculous amounts of fun.

Manveer is up in the corner, the crazy guy is yours truly

Tonight Manveer and I FaceTimed. It’s the feature I wish we had when we were back in middle school. These days it’s a lot harder to explain why you’ve got some random dude’s face on your phone talking to you about completely pointless things at 12:54AM on a Tuesday night. I spent part of the chat covering one of the lights in my room with my head and calling it an Anand Head Eclipse. At the risk of further embarrassing myself publicly, it was fun.

For those of you who don’t know, FaceTime is Apple’s VoIP protocol built into the iPhone 4.

Granted we’ve been able to do this sort of thing for quite a while now over instant messenger networks. Integration into your smartphone is just the next logical step, and in the right conditions it works very well.

The first requirement is that both users need to have an iPhone 4 obviously. Both also need to be on WiFi. While the FaceTime icon will appear if you call another iPhone 4, if you try to activate the connection you’ll get this error unless you’re on WiFi:

With a bit of poor UI design Apple will actually display a FaceTime icon with a question mark in it if you call another iOS phone. Trying to activate FaceTime however gives you an error.

FaceTime requires roughly 100 - 150Kbps of bandwidth in both directions to work smoothly. The download should be fine but the upload is pretty high given that many broadband providers in the US are ridiculously stingy with their upload bandwidth. For FaceTime to work well you can’t be uploading or downloading anything large in the background, or if you are just throttle everything else to give you enough bandwidth to work with.

The next problem with FaceTime is the iPhone 4 lacks an absolutely necessary integrated stand. HTC got it perfect with the EVO 4G, unfortunately the 4 has no such thing. The closest you can get is Apple’s iPhone 4 dock, it’ll set you back $29 but it’s necessary to prevent you from getting tired holding your phone out in front of you. Laying the 4 down on your desk while you FaceTime just gives the person on the other end of the line a great view of your nostrils. Not very welcoming.

This is the on-table view of FaceTime, you need a stand

Even once you’ve met all of the requirements it’s still not a guaranteed thing. Even with ample bandwidth I had one FaceTime chat stall in the middle of the chat. My incoming feed froze and I had to wait a couple of seconds for it to resume. I also had a problem where FaceTime would fail to start on the first try. A subsequent try fixed it.

As you'll see in our camera investigation, the low light performance of the 4's front facing camera is horrid. Couple that with FaceTime and you will get bad image quality if you're not in a well lit room:

Ugh, what is this, 1998?

While in FaceTime you can easily switch between front and rear cameras by tapping the camera icon in the lower right corner. Unfortunately the compression on the video is enough to render text illegible while in FaceTime:

This was taken using the rear facing camera over FT

Obviously everyone knows where FaceTime is going. Apple is supposedly opening the protocol up to all developers, so you’d be able to theoretically build desktop and other smartphone FaceTime clients. And ultimately as mobile broadband speeds (hello WiMAX and LTE) improve the WiFi requirement will be dropped. But is it a good feature today?

It really depends on who you know with an iPhone 4. If you’ve got a Manveer, absolutely - the feature is worth it. If you have a bunch of casual acquaintances with iPhone 4s, probably not. It’s only useful if you know the person on the other side very well.

There is one other major benefit to FaceTime. Once enabled your call is routed over WiFi to the Internet, not AT&T’s 3G network. It doesn’t use any of your plan’s minutes and more importantly, voice quality is much improved over a regular 3G/EDGE phone call. It’s VoIP, not a crappy cell connection. Even if you just cover the camera it’s actually better to make calls over FaceTime than 3G based on the sound quality alone.

Camera Usability Sidebar: Luxa2 H1-Touch, a Great FaceTime Stand


View All Comments

  • Acel-cr - Wednesday, August 11, 2010 - link

    iBand Aid Antenn-aid for iPhone 4 is a custom sized vinyl sticker for your iPhone 4. When placed over the lower left corner of the antenna it may improve signal performance.

    Antenn-aids act as a Band-Aid for iPhones
    and are designed to be placed over the lower left corner of the antenna, in the area where the signal dropping issues occur.

    Almost any mobile phone in certain ways will reduce its reception by 1 or more bars. This is true of iPhone 4, iPhone 3GS, as well as many Droid, Nokia and RIM phones. But some users have reported that iPhone 4 can drop 4 or 5 bars when tightly held in a way which covers the black strip in the lower left corner of the metal band.

    Gorgeous colors
    Each iBand Aid package has seven gorgeous colored stickers. Colours: patch, silver, dark gray, turquoise, lime, pink and white

  • nfl2shop - Thursday, August 12, 2010 - link

    Two neurosurgeons speak to Cheap NFL Jerseys, players association, teams about safety Hopkins Medicine conference, www.NFL2shop.com
    If you need more info about NFL jerseys,welcome visit to www.NFL2shop.com
  • sophiamake - Sunday, August 15, 2010 - link

    Brorsoft MOD to Adobe Premiere Pro Converter for MAC, convert MOD to MOV for Adobe Premiere Pro

    MOD and TOD are informal names of tapeless video formats used by JVC (MOD and TOD), Panasonic (MOD only) and Canon (MOD only) in some models of digital camcorders. Format names correspond to extensions of video files. Neither JVC nor Panasonic, who pioneered the format, explained meaning of the file extensions, and the formats were never given an official name. MOD is used exclusively for standard definition video files, while TOD is used for high definition files.

    HD camcorders, like JVC GZ-MG670, Panasonic SDR-H200 and Canon FS100, with the extension of .mod and .tod have a growing popularity, but MOD/TOD video file conversion an editing becomes a headache issue due to the uncommon of video format. Like, Final Cut Express and Adobe Premiere Pro, the first choice editing software for Mac users, do not allowed to edit MOD/TOD files directly. These video recording can be imported into both of editing software as long as you convert MOD/TOD video files into formats editable in Final Cut Express and Adobe Premiere Pro, like QuickTime MOV.

    As for MOD/TOD converter, I recommend Brorsoft MOD Converter for Mac working as the best MOD to MOV Converter which is professional and powerful in converting MOD video files into some portable and editable video formats. Due to its intuitive and easy to use feature, just by tree steps, you can accomplish the MOD to MOV conversion.

    The just click three steps will shown as bellow:

    Step 1: Import MOD video files into this Brorsoft MOD Converter for Mac.
    Drag MOD video files into this software or click "Add" button the bar menu to load MOD video files. And batch video files are allowed to be loaded for conversion.

    Step 2: Select the output format and specify the destination folder.
    Choose "QuickTime MOV" as the output video format from "Common video" section from "Format" drop list. Then, you can specify the folder which you would like to put the converted video file.

    Step 3: Join video files (Optional) and start MOD to MOV conversion.
    For smoothly editing and playing, combine your imported video files into big one by ticking the checkbox of "Merge into one file". Finally, click the big button of "Convert" to begin this conversion.

    After a while, MOV video file is ready for you to edit and perfect on Final Cut Express and Adobe Premiere Pro

    1.If you own a JVC camcorders, like JVC GZ-HD7 and JVC GZ-HD30 which produces the video file of TOD, please check Brorsoft TOD Converter for Mac.
    Final Cut Express is non-linear video editing application created by Apple Inc. It is the consumer version of Final Cut Pro and is designed for advanced editing digital video as well as high-definition video. But only Final Cut Express 4 and the latter version supports real-time editing in the AVCHD format (currently for Intel processors only), imports iMovie '08 projects and includes 50 new filters.

    Adobe Premiere Pro is a real-time, timeline based video editing software application. Premiere Pro supports many video editing cards and plug-ins for accelerated processing, additional file format support and video/audio effects. Although the first two versions of Premiere Pro only supported Windows, Premiere Pro CS3 is available for both Windows and Mac OS (only Intel-based Macs are supported), making it one of the few cross-platform NLEs available. And now Adobe Premiere Pro CS4 supports ACVHD format but not in the trial version.
  • topclothing - Friday, August 20, 2010 - link

    want to be fashion? here is : http://www.worldtopclothing.com Reply
  • topclothing - Friday, August 20, 2010 - link

    want to do it? go to http://www.cheap4clothing.com Reply
  • topclothing - Friday, August 20, 2010 - link

    jump more higher? go to http://www.worldtopclothing.com Reply
  • topclothing - Friday, August 20, 2010 - link

    to be great star? go to http://www.cheap2jersey.com Reply
  • gregnewton - Wednesday, August 25, 2010 - link

    I found these great guys - www.ihandystore.com
    They are the only one seller of micro sim adapters in UK and I just get mine. I must say I didn't thought it would be so cool, it's just what I was needed, it does the trick and I think I saved a lot of money with that thing. They also offer these cool looking skins called iDecal case, I think I'm gona try it out, it should give my iPhone 4 a great individual look.
    Be sure to check them out these guys can be trusted.
  • marxster - Thursday, September 09, 2010 - link

    ...after all that, I'll give you my real world experience. We have a 3Gs and a 4 in our household. The 3Gs always shows more bars and does not drop calls at all while my iPhone 4 does drop calls and has less bars.

    We live far away from the closest tower and the iphone 4 doesn't ever get better reception here than -103db.

    I'm now afraid to receive calls because I know they'll be dropped. Makes my phone useless.

    I should say that both phones are on the latest iOS version and there isn't much of a difference whether I use a case or not.

    By the way, please explain this to me. Why did Apple bother to spend millions of dollars shipping out cases when they clearly don't get rid of the problem. When I cup my phone with the case on, the bars drop just the same as without.
  • dnghiem - Friday, October 15, 2010 - link

    Thanks so much for the info. Please visit http://www.GlobalEnvironmentCenter.com to learn more about the cell-phone issues and solutions. Reply

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now