Thoughts

by Anand Lal Shimpi on April 6, 2005 6:40 PM EST
$26

My dad came to this country with something like $26 in his pocket; $26 and a scholarship to UMASS. I didn't know about that until I was around 14, our family went to another family's house for dinner and it came up in after dinner conversation. I was honestly floored - all of the sudden everything in life made sense to me, I was given the drive that I needed to go anywhere and do anything in life. My dad took essentially nothing and raised a family out of it; we all helped, but one man's ability to do that is what I truly define as successful. We weren't rich, but he (along with the help of my mom) made sure that we could live in comfort as a family. My dad is what sparked my drive; he's the reason that if I get a product to review on Friday, and the review has to go up on Monday, I bust my ass all weekend to make sure it gets done. He instilled in me a true understanding of what hard work is really about, and that's a major cornerstone of who I am today.

My mom gave me an understanding of how to do something with myself and an understanding of ethics. She showed me what truly caring about something really meant, about what being selfless meant and gave me the foundation that allowed me to develop my own perspectives on the world. She didn't teach me right from wrong, she taught me how to figure out what's right and what's wrong. And I'll never forget that which she's taught me to this day. It wasn't until college that I really understood what she had done for me; she dropped out of college to take care of me, to raise me. She gave up her dreams of being a doctor, to live her new dream of having a son. She cared for me more than anyone ever could, and seeing and understanding that also helped shaped who I am today.

I started AnandTech almost exactly 8 years ago: April 26, 1997. I was a freshman in high school, 14 at the time, and completely into this stuff. I started AnandTech not as a business, but as something that I thought would be cool to do. I started it humble, and to this day I will never forget my beginnings. There's no room for big egos in writing, I hate reading it and I'm sure you all do too.

I started the website with nothing, it was a free site on Geocities and I had no hardware other than the scraps of my system. But I worked hard these past 8 years, AnandTech grew from nothing to where it is today - with over 6 million monthly unique readers. I've had one basic principle when it comes to how to deal with those readers, and it goes something like this:

Regardless of how many people come to the site, I look at it as each person coming to me with their money in hand, wanting to know what to purchase. Let's say the average hardware upgrade costs $150, that's 6 million people x $150. I don't have to let you know that that's an absolutely ridiculous amount of money. To trade the trust that you all are placing in me and my staff for any amount of anything, is just unfathomable. While I'm sure there are folks that do it, I am not one of them.

At the same time, if we didn't value your trust so highly, we'd be gone in an instant. AnandTech readers make their buying decisions based, in part, on our articles. If we gave some bad advice that resulted in a poor purchase, do you think we're going to keep those readers for long? Nope, common sense right?

Next let's talk about this myth of articles and exclusivity. To a journalist, an exclusive on an article is a huge deal, because it means that you'll get all the attention about this one topic. Yet another reason why I hate journalists, they are far too short sighted. One thing I learned very early on (and you'll notice this in the work I do) is that being first to break a story gives you a large influx of short term traffic, but does nothing for you long term. You can have all the exclusives in the world, but if your content is crap then they mean nothing. At the same time, you can be 3 weeks late to review something, but if it's the most thorough review out there, that review's overall impact on reader perception of you and your site is much greater than having an exclusive. Now if you can get a review out first and make it as thorough as possible, then you're sitting pretty.

The next part of the myth of an exclusive is this idea that manufacturers have any desire to give one site an exclusive over another - that simply doesn't happen. Any of the "exclusive" articles we've done over the past 8 years have been made possible through going through third parties. I reviewed the K6-III about 3 months before AMD even shipped the review samples, did AMD work out a sweetheart deal with me? Of course not, I went around the manufacturer. It's what I did for the SLI preview from last year, it's what we do to get company roadmaps. We avoid dealing with the manufacturer at all costs, unless we need to talk to their engineers.

It's true that manufacturers try to bully a lot of sites out there, generally speaking the smaller you are, the more the manufacturer tries to influence you. I fought very hard to build AnandTech to where it is today, and it is at the point where manufacturers do not even *dare* try to even hint at trying to influence anything. All of the major manufacturers have done their own independent audits of AnandTech, they know how large we are and the type of influence we have - do you think they'd risk a story about how they are trying to strong arm the media into reviewing products a certain way?

"But what about the advertisers?" you say, well, I took care of that problem long ago. AnandTech as a company doesn't have a single sales person on staff, years ago I set things up so that we wouldn't have to deal with advertisers and to truly build a separation between editorial and advertising. The results of this are numerous, but the two major ones are:

1) I like my editors to be autonomous, they receive a little direction from me and help if they need it, otherwise they are on their own to do and review anything you ask for and they see as important to the areas of coverage. They are never told what to review or how to review it; honestly, if this weren't the case, you all would see right through it.

2) I rarely know about what ads are going live on the site unless I either see them while browsing the site, or in my CEO role someone from the sales side brings one up to discuss. Honestly I'm far too busy to even bother with that sort of stuff; you guys follow the blog, there's no time for me to be running around working on ad stuff. I've got people to handle that, they do their job and we do ours.

Advertisers will sometimes ask for preferential treatment, if they ask our sales folks directly - they are turned down on the spot. Sometimes they will go around them and talk directly to an editor, if they do, the editor makes it *very* clear that we don't work this way - case closed. I've got tons of emails of this kind of stuff, and as I mentioned before, by now about 99% of the manufacturers don't even try this sort of crap. They know where it's going to get them and that I take it very personally. The remaining 1% are folks that haven't dealt with us before, they'll learn soon enough. Do others have this separation? Most don't. Does that mean anything? I can't speak for them, but I can speak for us and this policy works for us. Do you have to be an advertiser to get a review? Of course not, anyone who reads this blog should know that if you all want to see us review something, we'll do it - all you have to do is ask :)

"But what about the free hardware?"

Manufacturers also know that we have no problems buying hardware, if they refuse to send us something, we'll just go out and buy it. I've had manufacturers refuse to send us products for a full year, but did you all notice? Nope...we just went out and bought everything. That's another philosophy of mine: you come here to read about technology, not about some soap opera and crap that goes on behind the scenes - so I keep things like that off the site. When there are problems with manufacturer relations, I don't post about them here, I deal with them maturely and in a way that doesn't affect the outcome of reviews. Manufacturers also know this, they can say whatever they want to me, about me, etc... but it still has no impact on our reviews. If company X calls me stupid, does it make sense for me to hurt *all of you* by giving an unfair/incorrect review of their product? A lot of these issues are just plain common sense :)

AnandTech is a business - we do make money, but regardless of how large we get and what our revenues are, it's still run like a family. And this family has morals, I can't speak for how other people were raised but this is how I was raised and it's how I run my family.
Comments Locked

72 Comments

View All Comments

  • Max - Friday, June 3, 2005 - link

    Just wanted to say I really enjoyed reading this post. It reminds me in some ways, of my own sense of morals and ethics.

    I've been a fan of yours from way back. I started a "PC repair and small office network" business in '97. Shortly after, I discovered your site, and it has been invaluable to me over the years for advise I can pass on to customers for their custom systems. In the early years, I spent a lot of time browsing around for reviews from every place I could find, but alway came back to AnandTech,I think, because I had a "sense" that it never sounded like a "biased" opinion. I really appreciate that (and so do my customers).

    I have to admit that my business has not been doing well lately, and I've been pursuing other interests more in the last year or two. I also admit that inspite of my engineering degree, and my experience with PC from the beginning (original IBM PC 1982), I am beginning to lose my basic understanding of these machines. The stuff you guys get into, is sometime beyond the reach of the "average joe". As much as it is fun to try to figure out what all that "jargon" means, I prefer a simpler approach (KISS)for most things I do. You might want to do some articles for us "joe's" out there. You now have the clout (read "market reach") that just about anyone close to the business knows about you site, but sometimes it's a little to technical to make sense of.

    Anyway best of luck on the future of your endeavor. It's good stuff.
  • ncelikgil - Tuesday, April 26, 2005 - link

    Hi Anand,
    The AX6BC Gold was editors choice in 1999. Based on your review I purchased and built one of the most incredibly stable and lasting machines I have ever owned. In fact It is still in use today 6 years....and still running like new. Anandtech is truly an oasis. The personal computer has become a utility like water?...or electricity? We can't live without this portal to the greater world. I remember the dark days before the web and before there was any such thing as Hardware review sites. "You were on your own in the jungle ready to gamble some cash on a Gateway or a Dell" Why becuase you had no choice. SO thanks Anand!! thank you for providing us with the information to make good choices and teaching us about the bleeding edge of Hardware for the PC enthusiast. It is indeed liberating...

    P.S. Please revisit your socket 939 editors choice for the "MSI k8n Neo2 Platinum" the web is littered with people who have had nothing but trouble from this motherboard. It may be a HOT ROD but not a "Work Horse". You are our voice. Don't forget us...





  • Captante - Sunday, April 24, 2005 - link

    Amen to that brother ... I've been reading your site for, oh about 8 years now & yours is one of the very few web-sites I still trust, keep up the good work Anand, & at the risk of repeating this for the 500th time, hopefully 8 years from now I'll still be around!
  • Bhuvnesh - Thursday, April 21, 2005 - link

    Well done Anand ! You have been doing for the last 8 years what Indian cricket team just could not think of doing with their recently ended series against Pakistan.

    Wish you many more years of success.
    ---Bhuvnesh---
  • Aamir - Thursday, April 21, 2005 - link

    Anand, A very heartfelt message to your readers. Yes, it did suggest that you were not too happy about the attack by the inquirer. Who cares, right? By providing unbiased information to your readers for so long, you've helped made many know-it-nots into something of know-their-tech people. I can't describe how much I've gleaned about new and upcoming technologies and existing ones merely by browsing through the copious amounts of information available here. From India, thanks Anand.

    -- Aamir --
  • Akshay - Thursday, April 21, 2005 - link

    Anand, Thanks for telling us your story. I am so glad i found this website years ago. In your journal you said it and i have been touched too. Thanks for telling us about your self.
    AT'er
    Akshay
  • Ionoxx - Wednesday, April 13, 2005 - link

    I know quite a few people have said the same, but one more can't hurt.

    Many thanks to you and your team Anand. Keep up the good work.
  • Dybo70 - Tuesday, April 12, 2005 - link

    Anand,

    Talk about inspiring! That was one blog entry long overdue! I have been coming to this site and reading your articles for longer than I can remember, but I don't think anything you've ever written has made me want to put up a post more than this!

    Too often today, people are blinded by themselves. We unfortunately live in a "what have you done for me lately" society, and all to frequently don't stop to think about the people that we interact with on a daily basis. Although you may not actually speak with many or any of us, you do interact with us through your articles and postings and it is a wonderful thing to see that you take it so seriously.

    It is good to know that when I come here looking for an opinion or information regarding a new product, service or idea, I will get an honest assessment from you and your staff. It is even better to know that I am getting this information from someone who shares the same values as I and that they were instilled in him much the same as they were in me when I was growing up. It leads me to believe that you are someone who truly understands your readers and there needs, and more importantly cares enough to give them that much and more!

    I congratulate you on your 8 year anniversary, and hope that there are many more to come! Keep the quality information coming our way, and I can guarantee you that we will all keep coming back for it! Thank You!
  • Jake - Saturday, April 9, 2005 - link

    You know what's coo is you follow what you preach. You said you dont like all the soap opera crap. You could have posted your comments regarding the current situation on the front of the page or in one of the links in bold and big in the news section or the middle. But you didnt. This came from your blog which is a small link in the bottom right with a oblivious name of "thoughts"

    I didnt even know about the whole inq stuff i just happen to see that you had a blog and wanted to check it out and ran into this. If i hadnt notice i would never know what's going on or all this stuff was happening.

    The point being. Its about the hardware reviews and it's always been. Before reading all this stuff, i was just doing what i normally would, go on AT and check out hardware reviews.


    Your actions do speak louder than your worlds. It shows.

    You must have done very well on your college entrance essay, cuz that was college application quality. I might use the same line of thought ;)
  • Brandon - Friday, April 8, 2005 - link

    Thanks Anand, that's why I've been a loyal reader for many YEARS. I appreciate all you do, and buy from Newegg by clicking on your link :)

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now