Back to Article

  • poohbear - Saturday, September 03, 2011 - link

    I'm still happy with my Corsair 600T which your review actually enticed me into buying! the only gripe is that the 600T is so huge!!! people visiting me usually gasp at how big it is & ask me why i need such a big case.:p Is the 400R more in line with the average size of a common computer case? carrying the 600T to LAN parties or to a friends house was always a pain in the butt, but its no biggie as i hardly ever do that. Reply
  • Impulses - Saturday, September 03, 2011 - link

    Outside of Silverstone's radical rotated designs, and the occasional Lian Li with the mobo mounted on the opposite side, there doesn't seem to be a whole lot of innovation going on as far as internal layouts. Why do so many cases keep trying to force air in an S shape from the bpttom front and out the back/top?

    Why not a more linear airflow design? The vast majority of people only have one optical drive, a few may have two or one and a media card reader, and there's certainly way more enthusiasts with one or more high powered GPU that generates more heat than their CPU...

    Soooo, why not move the PSU to it's original top location so it's in line with one or two optical bays, then have a 120mm intake directly below those, in line with the fan on most tower coolers and the rear exhaust... Thus creating a direct path for airflow. Then just have a large side intake over the GPUs which usually vent out the back, could even toss in some sorta adjustable divider to separate the GPU(s) from the stuff above 'em.

    It wouldn't be an ideal layout for people with tons of drives, but I don't think most people running a home server are also having the same rig serve double duty as a gaming rig. Or male a wider/shorter case where optical drives mount vertically along fan mounts (leaving plenty of room for cable management and tall coolers in the process), with hard drive mounts all along the bottom next to a bottom mounted PSU.

    That's what bothers me about all these enthusiast cases, so much wasted drive bay space, it's probably not even good for air circulation. There's really a market for SFF and cases that could hold a high end rig and over a dozen drives but there isn't a market for someone that just wants optimal linear airflow for a high end rig period?
  • cactusdog - Saturday, September 03, 2011 - link

    Because then you have a pocket of non circulating air in the bottom half of the case. The traditional method of taking air in at the bottom and out at the top has lasted so long because it works and its the most efficient. Reply
  • lwatcdr - Saturday, September 03, 2011 - link

    The simple answer is the universe sucks.
    You do not want "Smooth air flow" for heat transfer, you want a turbulent airflow. If air flows smoothly you get what is called a boundary layer which is very sluggish and almost stops. It acts as an insulator. Or course it takes more power and makes more noise to have turbulent airflow.
    Now the positive pressure idea is a very good one. Increasing the pressure in the case means more mass to remove the heat. Of course because the universe does suck when you pressurize a gas it gets hotter but the increase in mass flow should make up for that.
  • mjsunkiter - Saturday, September 03, 2011 - link

    This logic in the first part of your statement is valid, involving turbulent flow.

    However, the second part is not so sound. Air moving at low speeds (<~0.3 Mach) is effectively incompressible, from a fluid flow standpoint. The increase in mass is negligible, the increase in pressure is effectively non-existent. The amount of heat generated by the fan motor is likely several order of magnitude higher than the increase in temperature of the air due to any compression.
  • superccs - Monday, September 05, 2011 - link

    I agree with most of this line of thought...

    I have one of those wierd Lian Lis with the mobo on the left side and the PSU infront. I can get some crazy back to front air flow that keeps the main components (GPU CPU) frosty and interal temps get to around 35C under load.

    What I do have are fans in specific areas of my case (on the inside) which evacuate the stagnant areas and utilize positive back to front high flow air stream. This lets my CPU and GPU get fresh air, which is then rapidly exhausted toward the front of the case. Exposing the 3-4 HDDs to a mild blast of warm air (big deal).

    Who is making modular cases these days that you can replace panels with to add of delete fan mount locations?
  • v12v12 - Sunday, September 18, 2011 - link

    Basically the traditional "PC" (non Apple) case uses the antiquated "warehouse" strategy... A big large box with many options for cooling and room for expansion. This works great for the serious hobbyist with tons of time and tools to get seriously creative. It does not work for those that do not and do not wish to invest said time and resources into a case that already is overpriced...

    People do you get it yet; CASES ARE OVERPRICED stamped/cut out cheap, LOW QUALITY ALLOY aluminum. It's not 6061t or 7000 aircraft grade. This stuff is the lowest grade recycled junk material; sure it works well for a case, but the PRICE does not at all reflect the quality of build/material. $100 for a box that takes no more than 20minutes to produce from start to finish on an assembly line.!??? STOP PAYING FOR JUNK AND SUPPORTING THE VENDORS OF THIS CRAP! OR... continue getting fleeced?????

    What I've always done is take ideas from basic HVAC systems and apply them like Apple has to their old G4-5 towers = ZONED COOLING separation. Your ideas are right in line with said practice; U ISOLATE heat zones and have dedicated fans cooling said zones. Theres some things I should clear up about turbulence and smooth flow; you want BOTH.

    Smoother flowing air EN ROUTE to the heat source(s) = faster flowing air = MORE turbulence once it strikes the intended heat source. You do NOT want turbulent air flow (slow and less controlled) before the air hits the heat sources... The speed produces the increased turbulence, which disrupts the boundary layer (this is minimal in a PC in most cases), which increases cooling efficiency.

    So in a PC case, you want to speed up the air before it reaches the heat source, then speed it up again once it has hit the heat source(s) so it can quickly be exhausted. You do this by taking some card board and tape and making a mock zoned ducting system to segregate components at the top and bottom and even within those diff zones themselves... Then take said cardboard and use it as a stencil to make a better looking/stronger (etc) zone from plastic, or other more durable materials. Personally corrugated cardboard + metallic ducting tape works well enough for me... I just take some spray paint and color the cardboard+tape and leave it be... It really does work wonders! The key is getting as MUCH OUTSIDE air into/out of the case as fast as audibly tolerable.... Zoned-cooling also lowers the noise factor by many decibels too!

    I hate to plug "Apple" but they are an engineering and design corp. They have a serious leg up as they can implement such technology and mandate it with out worry of issue from consumers... If a PC case maker tries and fails to sell they risk losing serious capital; Apple never worries, their user based will take it up their arse or forced spoon-fed in their maws lol. Apple's got the leg up on "PC" cases.
  • Malih - Saturday, September 03, 2011 - link

    In my setup I install Side Intake fans and also Top Exhausts (hot air rises thingie) and a Bottom Intake (I have the a CM690 with Side Window) and they work quite well.

    I just thought if you want to test a case maximum cooling performance, might as well install all the fans, althought I'll admit I'm not really knowledgeable on this area. Your thoughts?
  • casteve - Saturday, September 03, 2011 - link

    ..but they significantly impede airflow causing higher temps and fan noise. Too bad the drive cage can't be removed. Reply
  • Khronikos - Saturday, September 03, 2011 - link

    I love my 690 ll advanced. After looking at a lot of other designs for my needs I still think I made the right choice. I do like the 700D as well quite a bit. This case looks a little wonky to me. Still very decent feature list. Reply
  • Death666Angel - Saturday, September 03, 2011 - link

    I don't understand that passage. I haven't used USB 3.0, yet. Is there some problem with booting from USB3.0 ports? Shouldn't they be backward compatible? :-)
    Thanks for the review! Could you add metric measurements? :-)
  • livingplasma - Saturday, September 03, 2011 - link

    I've had much better luck with side fans being used as exhaust rather than intake. This was true when I tested with my an Antec Three Hundred with a 4890 non reference that exhausts from the back and front, there was a slight advantage with the side fans as exhaust under load. With aftermarket cpu coolers like the Scythe Setsugen 2, the cooling advantage was even greater. CPU and board temps were also lower than with the side fans as intake. Only during idle or cpu only loads did side fans as intake performed a little bit better. Same results even with a pair of 6870's in the Cooler Master 690 II. Another interesting thing I've noticed is that all the fans I've tried are less noisey when pushing through a grill vent rather than trying to suck air through them. Reply
  • ckryan - Saturday, September 03, 2011 - link

    I guess you have to admire what corsair is doing, even If I don't find the exterior to be particularly sexified. For an attractive, unusual, and generally backassward affair, see the Lian Li PC A05NB. I've been a hopeless shill for it for some time now, but a little Corsair magic on the inside wouldn't hurt (much).

    Hey, another case review so soon? Awesome.
  • B3an - Sunday, September 04, 2011 - link

    Can you start reviewing cases like this that actually look nice and not like cheap tacky crap like they were designed by a 12 year old? I know they're very rare but these mythical beasts do exist! Reply
  • Dustin Sklavos - Monday, September 05, 2011 - link

    Well shoot, I was just going to try and review as many bug ugly cases as I possibly could, but since you made the request I'll get right on it! Reply
  • TrackSmart - Monday, September 05, 2011 - link

    I checked out the Lian Li PC A05NB (mentioned by ckryan above). For $90 on Newegg, I'm pretty curious to see how it would compare. The Corsair is not awful, but I still wouldn't put it in my living room. The Lian Li case, however, is undersstated enough to go anywhere.

    Maybe Dustin can request one of the Lian Li's for a showdown - if he isn't already buried in cases to review.
  • softdrinkviking - Monday, September 05, 2011 - link

    i just put together one of these for my dad, and it was great to work with. I didn't cut my hand even once!

    also, the usb 3.0 on the front is a huge plus if your popping external drives on/off all the time.

    one thing I did differently was I mounted the PSU upside-down becasue the holes on my seasonic didn't line-up properly otherwise.
  • AssBall - Wednesday, September 07, 2011 - link

    If your PSU fan is on the bottom, like many, you'd want to mount it upside down anyway. Reply
  • wyhtmgm - Friday, October 14, 2011 - link

    I have a 650TXV2. The holes on the PS aren't symmetrical, but the holes on the case are symmetrical so it lines up the same way whether it's rightside up or upside down, i.e. I didn't encounter softdrinkviking's problem. I'm not that happy about how it lines up, since the head of one of the screws is sort of holding against the edge of sheet metal instead of going through a hole, but I haven't installed a power supply in years so maybe that's normal.

    Is the power supply in the review picture rightside up or upside down? In the picture I don't see the fan, which suggests rightside up, but the picture may just be too dark. There are other clues that it could be upside down; the position of the cables, and there's no visible label on top.

    The PS would probably run cooler rightside up, but my floor tends to be dusty and I don't like the idea of blowing dust into the PS.
  • Valitri - Wednesday, September 21, 2011 - link

    I currently use a CM 690 with 4 Yate Loon 120mm fans (1 front intake, 1 rear exhaust, 2 on Hyper 212+ push/pull out the back), and 3 Cheap NZXT White 140mm fans (1 bottom intake, 2 top exhaust, NZXT cheap white ones). The case has been banged up during moves and 3 different builds in it. I also redrywalled a room it was in so it's not clean either. I just ordered this 400R and will be ordering a few new fans for it as well. I curently load 54C on my 2500k at 4.5ghz after about an hour of Prime, so I'll test that against the 400R. I am also curious if my 6970 will run cooler if I install side fans on the 400R. The way my side panels work on my 690, I don't have room for side fans. The most important thing to me will probably be noise, I wish I had a way to accurately measure it. My case is very loud, and my fans seem to rattle sometimes. Reply
  • SuperGazerBeam - Thursday, April 19, 2012 - link

    Is it possible to replace the two fans in the front. For example to install 2 120 mm RED LED fans Reply

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now