LRDIMMs, RDIMMs, and Supermicro's Latest Twin

26 Comments

View All Comments

• ddr3memory - Monday, August 6, 2012 - link

  Your article is very interesting - and the first mainstream (and belated) examination of the LRDIMM (new standard - incompatible with RDIMMs) vs. HCDIMM (100% DDR3 RDIMM compatbile) choice for Romley.
  
  I have whittled down the use case for HCDIMMs/LRDIMMs and RDIMMs as follows:
  
  The HCDIMM use case is at:
  - 16GB at 3 DPC use
  - 32GB (outperform both RDIMMs and LRDIMMs)
  
  LRDIMMs are not viable at:
  - 16GB (RDIMMs are better)
  - 32GB (HCDIMMs are better)
  
  RDIMMs are not viable at:
  - 32GB (because they are 4-rank - trumped by LRDIMMs/HCDIMMs)
  
  There is a reason the Netlist HCDIMMs were only released on the virtualization servers from IBM/HP - because at 16GB levels the only niche available for LRDIMM/HCDIMM vs. RDIMM is the 3 DPC space. This will expand considerably at 32GB to mainstream levels as soon as 32GB HCDIMMs are released (they are currently in qualification with IBM/HP and have not been announced yet - though maybe expected shortly).
  
  I had created an infographic covering the memory choices - search the net for the article entitled:
  
  Infographic - memory buying guide for Romley 2-socket servers
  
  HCDIMMs are not available at SuperMicro (as they are for IBM/HP) - so I was surprised you even covered HCDIMMs (since the article is after all referring to the SuperMicro line of servers).

• Casper42 - Friday, August 10, 2012 - link

  BTW, Johan, I work for HP and asked some of the guys in ISS Technical Marketing why we don't send you our servers for eval like you get from SuperMicro and sometimes Dell
  
  They felt that you guys didn't do alot of Server Reviews, and that your readership wasn't generally the kind of folks that buy HP Servers.
  
  So I am curious if you could spin up a poll or something in the future to prove them wrong.
  If there is enough support I'm sure we can you some gear to play with.
  
  I sometimes giggle when I see the stuff people on here get excited about in these reviews though. "Can you see the BIOS through IPMI?". Thats the kind of thing Compaq offered back with the RILOE II and have been integrated into the motherboard since iLO 1 which is like 4 or 5 years old at least.
  iLO4 on the Gen8 line have taken that a step further and we now hook the Display system BEFORE POST starts so instead of an invalid memory config getting you a series of beeps, you now get a full blown screen either on local VGA or on the Remote Console that straight up tells you you have a memory mismatch and why. i have seen his demo'd with NO DIMMs even installed in the server and you still get Video and obvious status messages.

• Casper42 - Friday, August 10, 2012 - link

  Also you are about $2000 high on the HP SL unless I am missing something.
  I found these prices with QuickSpecs part numbers and Google, nothing magical inside HP.
  
  Half of one of these:
  http://www.provantage.com/hewlett-packard-hp-62923...
  Includes 8 fans and 3 PS
  
  2 of these
  http://www.provantage.com/hewlett-packard-hp-65904...
  2x2665 with 8GB
  
  Comes to about $11,600

• JohanAnandtech - Tuesday, August 14, 2012 - link

  Hey Casper, contact me on my mail... thx!

• ad99 - Monday, April 1, 2013 - link

  You say：a quad rank DIMM with 4Gb chips is a 32GB DIMM (4 Gbit x 8 x 4 ranks)，but I think 4 Gbit x 8 x 4 ranks make only 16GB,is that right?

• ad99 - Monday, April 1, 2013 - link

  No,4 Gbit x 8 x 4 ranks should be 128GB，not 32GB or 16GB,is that right?