Real World Tests - Multitasking Performance

To provide a real world example of multitasking we use run Outlook and import 450MB of emails into an account. We then time how long it takes our benchmarking utlity to zip a single 300MB file. To compare our results we calculate the difference between the multitasked process and the single task file zip process.

Outlook + File Zip 1 300MB File
NCQ/TCQ Status
Multitasked
File Zip Only
% Difference
Hitachi T7K250
w/out NCQ
76.543
67.057
12.39%
w/NCQ
79.815
65.641
21.6%
Samsung HD160JJ
w/out NCQ
71.484
58.805
21.6%
w/NCQ
73.554
61.068
20.4%
Western Digital WD1600JS
N/A
74.371
61.182
21.6%

Very disappointing. Hitachi's T7K250 performed better than the rest in this real world multitasking test...with NCQ turned off! Now, drive manufacturers list NCQ as a native feature, but it does not seem to work too well in real world situations. As we look at products in the future, we hope to see atleast some improvement given by Native Command Queuing.

Multitasking Performance - Business Winstone 2004 Thermal and Acoustics
Comments Locked

52 Comments

View All Comments

  • ChiefNutz - Saturday, June 25, 2005 - link

    is it just me or is this review coming in without graphs, and a final conclusion?
  • KeithP - Saturday, June 25, 2005 - link

    haha

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now